Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

S&P 500 More Volatile Than Bitcoin as U.S. Assets Lose Investor Favor

What to know:

  • Bitcoin's volatility has decreased compared to the S&P 500, evolving as a low-beta play against stocks.
  • Investors are moving away from U.S. assets, causing a rise in Treasury yields and a decline in the dollar index and U.S. stocks.

For years, Wall Street criticized bitcoin (BTC) for its volatility, but the situation has dramatically changed as President Donald Trump's aggressive trade policies diminish the appeal of U.S. assets.

Since Trump's Liberation Day tariff announcement on April 2, the seven-day realized volatility of the S&P 500, Wall Street's benchmark equity index, has surged from an annualized 50% to 169%, according to data from TradingView. That's the highest level since the coronavirus crash in 2020.

BTC's seven-day realized volatility has doubled to 83%, yet it remains significantly lower than the S&P 500, hinting at the cryptocurrency's possible evolution as a low-beta hedge against stocks. The cryptocurrency also looks significantly less volatile than the S&P 500 on a 30-day basis.

"Equity markets [have] experienced a dramatic spike in volatility—surpassing that of Bitcoin, which is currently seeing a decline in volatility. This raises the question: should investors place their trust in assets that are highly susceptible to political influence and human error, or in a mathematical framework and emerging store of value that is more resilient to such risks?" CoinShares' Head of Research James Butterfill said in an email.

Investors dump U.S. assets

The S&P 500 has cracked 14% in less than two months, largely due to trade war fears that have recently come true. The tech-heavy Nasdaq and Dow Jones Industrial Average have suffered similar losses alongside increased volatility in global equity markets.

Risk aversion of such magnitudes has historically seen investors park money in Treasury notes, which underpin the global financial system, and the U.S. dollar, the global reserve currency.

But since last Friday, investors have aggressively dumped Treasury notes, driving yields higher, and the dollar index has tanked. The so-called benchmark 10-year bond yield has surged by 62 basis points to 4.45% since last Friday and the dollar index, which tracks the greenback's value against major currencies, has extended its first quarter swoon to 100, the lowest level since late September.

Currencies typically appreciate when their national bond yields rise unless markets are worried about the country's debt situation, in which case investors pull money out of the bond markets, leading to a spike in yields and a concurrent currency depreciation. The Global South witnessed this in 2018.

"Yields higher, currency lower is common in EM. We saw this in the UK during the Truss debacle. But it is highly abnormal for the US: there are only four other episodes in the last 30 years in which the dollar depreciated more than 1.5% with the 30-year yield up more than 10bp," Evercore ISI said, according to Wall Street Journal's Chief Economic Correspondent Nick Timaros.

"It reflects evaporating US growth exceptionalism and the reduced attraction at the margin of dollar assets for reserve purposes amid erratic US decision-making," Evercore added.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Federal Reserve Raises Interest Rates by 25 Basis Points for the First Time in Three Years

    On September 17, the Federal Reserve raised interest rates by 25 basis points, increasing the benchmark rate to 3.75%-4.00%. This marks the first rate hike since July 2023 and aligns with market expectations, following five consecutive meetings where the Fed maintained its stance.

  • BTC Surpasses $76,000

    Market data shows that BTC has surpassed $76,000, currently priced at $76,009.56, with a 24-hour decline of 1.23%. The market is highly volatile, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • ETH Falls Below $2400

    Market data shows that ETH has fallen below $2400, currently priced at $2399.94, with a 24-hour decline of 3.39%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • US Spot Bitcoin ETF Sees Net Outflow of $450.4 Million Yesterday

    On September 16, according to monitoring by Trader T, the US spot Bitcoin ETF experienced a net outflow of $450.4 million yesterday.

  • US Spot Ethereum ETF Sees Net Outflow of $142.3 Million Yesterday

    On September 16, according to monitoring by Trader T, the US spot Ethereum ETF experienced a net outflow of $142.3 million yesterday.

  • Senate Banking Committee Chair: CLARITY Act Fails to Advance Due to Democratic Opposition, SEC and CFTC Should Establish Digital Asset Rules

    On September 16, Tim Scott, Chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, stated that today, nearly all Senate Republican members voted in favor of advancing the CLARITY Act, but the motion ultimately failed to secure enough votes due to opposition from Senate Democrats. We have taken a step forward. Now, before Congress completes legislation, it is up to the SEC and CFTC to establish clear regulatory rules for digital assets. I remain focused on single mothers and Americans living in poverty, as I grew up in similar circumstances. I will continue to work to protect their hard-earned money and ensure the future of the financial industry remains in the United States.

  • Galaxy CEO: CLARITY Act Fails Due to Bipartisan Ethical Disagreements, SEC and CFTC to Continue Regulatory Efforts

    On September 16, Galaxy CEO Mike Novogratz stated, "The government seems to be paralyzed. Our industry has worked with both Democrats and Republicans for 18 months, yet the CLARITY Act has faltered just five yards from the finish line. All disputes, except for one issue, were resolved through hard negotiations. That issue is ethics. Both sides have held firm to their positions on ethics, ultimately deeming their stance more important than the long-term interests of a significant industry and the opportunity for the U.S. to lead in this sector. Republicans are concerned about imposing real restrictions on the President's ability to profit from digital assets; Democrats have decided to use this industry as a battleground in their fight against corruption. They worry about any actions that could be interpreted as showing a "soft stance" towards the President. Previously, there was a bipartisan proposal that could have resolved this issue, but it ultimately got caught up in political maneuvering. I am very disappointed that neither side was able to find a way across this divide. I know that with only seven weeks until the election, this has largely driven both parties' actions. However, what is truly perplexing is that I do not believe cryptocurrency and this bill will be among the top ten issues in this election. In 2024, yes, but this year's focus will be on war, inflation, cost of living, artificial intelligence, immigration, and which party can provide better solutions to these issues. Nonetheless, I still believe that the SEC and CFTC will continue to advance the development of regulatory rules for digital assets. I hope that over time, Congress will eventually find a way to formally legislate these rules, allowing market participants to build longer-term confidence in how digital assets will be regulated in the U.S. Perhaps Mitch McConnell returning to Congress in a wheelchair after a 90-day break is itself a rather ironic signal, further highlighting the predicament Congress is currently in. Tomorrow we continue to work. We keep building.

  • BTC Falls Below $76,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $76,000, currently priced at $75,944.3, with a 24-hour decline of 4.09%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • BTC Surpasses $77,000

    Market data shows that BTC has surpassed $77,000, currently priced at $77,007.69, with a 24-hour decline narrowing to 2.2%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • Becerra: We Can Start Paying Off Debt When Deficit Reaches 3% of GDP

    U.S. Treasury Secretary Becerra: We can start paying off debt when the deficit reaches 3% of GDP.