Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Crypto leaders are wrong about tokenized property

Validated Individual Expert

Opinion by: Darren Carvalho, Co-Founder and Co-CEO of MetaWealth

During Paris Blockchain Week, Securitize Chief Operating Officer Michael Sonnenshein made headlines by dismissing real estate as a sub-optimal asset class for tokenization. This isn’t the first time crypto leaders have underestimated the merits of bringing real estate onchain, and it is likely not the last. While I respect Sonnenshein’s contributions to digital asset adoption, his assessment misses fundamental points about real estate tokenization’s transformative potential.

Real estate represents the world’s largest asset class and is projected to reach a value of $654.39 trillion this year, according to Statista. When industry leaders claim that this massive market isn’t suitable for tokenization, they overlook today's transformative infrastructure and the core value proposition that extends far beyond liquidity, transforming access to the asset class.

Replacing traditional foundations

Sonnenshein argues that “good systems” already exist for traditional assets. He implies that tokenization offers marginal improvements at best, but this assessment overlooks fundamental inefficiencies in today’s real estate market that tokenization addresses.

The current real estate transaction process involves weeks of paperwork. Within the UK, there are a number of purchasing fees which can easily add 10% to the total bill. Settlement periods can extend to months and complexity multiplies exponentially for cross-border transactions.

These aren’t minor flaws. They’re systemic failures that tokenization technology is uniquely positioned to solve. Take smart contracts’ ability to automate compliance, for instance, enabling verification and payment distribution while reducing fraud through immutable record-keeping.

Redefining demand beyond liquidity

When Sonnenshein says “the onchain economy is demanding more liquid assets,” he misinterprets what everyday investors truly demand. For the 99% excluded from institutional-grade real estate investments, the primary task is not Bitcoin-like liquidity; it’s meaningful access to an asset class that has built more wealth than any other over the past century.

Traditional real estate investment vehicles require significant sums as minimum investments, accredited investor status and multi-year capital lockup periods. These barriers effectively exclude teachers, nurses and middle-class families from participating in prime real estate properties that have historically delivered consistent returns for investors.

Tokenization fundamentally changes this equation. Fractionalizing ownership through tokenization, investors can now participate with as little as $100, receive proportional income distributions and eventually trade their positions on specialized secondary markets. The demand for this democratized access is enormous, even if secondary market liquidity initially lags behind liquid markets.

Translation problems? Not quite

Sonnenshein also suggests that tokenization does not “translate well” to representing ownership in real estate. This assessment overlooks the blockchain’s revolutionary capability to enable fractional investments in properties that were previously accessible only to institutional investors.

Tokenization technology excels precisely at creating transparent, secure fractional investment opportunities with minimal overhead. A $50 million residential development project can be divided into 500,000 tokens, each getting an equal share of the rental income and potential appreciation. This dramatically lowers barriers to entry while maintaining the core benefits of real estate as an asset class.

This fractionalization fundamentally transforms how people can build wealth through real estate. Previously, REITs offered the only realistic path to diversified property exposure, often with high fees, no control and limited transparency. Tokenization allows investors to build personalized portfolios across multiple property types, all managed through a single digital wallet.

What does not “translate well” isn’t the technology. Outdated regulatory frameworks and incumbent business models resist this necessary evolution. The UAE government recognizes this reality, supported by its recent initiative to tokenize $1 billion in real estate assets.

Building tomorrow’s infrastructure

The conservative stance on RWA growth projections misses the accelerating infrastructure development underway. BlackRock’s tokenized money market fund BUIDL is quickly approaching $3 billion in assets, demonstrating a significant institutional appetite for tokenized investment vehicles. This isn’t an isolated case.

UBS Asset Management, Hamilton Lane, Franklin Templeton and many more have launched tokenized investment vehicles, signaling a fundamental shift in how traditional finance views tokenization technology.

What critics consistently underestimate is the network effect of financial infrastructure. Each institutional entrant doesn’t just add linearly to the ecosystem. It exponentially increases connectivity and liquidity pools. We’re witnessing the early stages of a self-reinforcing cycle where each new participant reduces friction for subsequent entrants.

The narrative shouldn’t center on current limitations. Instead, there should be a spotlight on what’s being built. Secondary marketplaces optimized for real-world assets are emerging, regulatory clarity is increasing in key jurisdictions, and each development strengthens the foundation for mass adoption at a pace that will likely surprise today’s skeptics.

Democratized wealth creation

Institutional investors have enjoyed privileged access to the most profitable real estate investments for decades, while retail investors were limited to residential properties or high-fee REITs. Tokenization breaks this paradigm by allowing anyone to build a diversified property portfolio spanning commercial, residential and industrial assets across multiple geographies.

When crypto leaders dismiss real estate tokenization based solely on liquidity metrics, they apply the wrong measurement standard. The transformative potential lies in democratizing access to an asset class that has created more millionaires than any other investment vehicle in history.

The endgame of real estate tokenization is making institutional-grade property investments accessible to everyone. The adoption of tokenized real estate and other real-world assets will continue to grow despite skepticism from executives who miss the forest for the trees.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • SEC Proposes Amendments to Transfer Agent Rules, Allowing Blockchain Ledgers as Official Records of Securities Ownership

    On September 11, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) proposed a new rule that aims to comprehensively amend the transfer agent rules that have been in place for decades. For the first time, the proposal explicitly allows electronic databases, including blockchain ledgers, to serve as official records of securities ownership. If approved, blockchain could become the 'primary securities document,' replacing the off-chain parallel ownership records that tokenized securities currently rely on. Currently, many tokenized securities operate on two sets of records: an on-chain token ledger and an official shareholder register. Once the proposal is passed, issuers and transfer agents may no longer need to maintain duplicate records and reconcile them after each transfer, thereby reducing operational friction and the risk of inconsistencies between on-chain records and legally recognized records. Eli Cohen, Chief Legal Officer of the tokenized fund platform Centrifuge, stated that this proposal could transform the current 'two-step' process into a 'one-step' process, allowing the blockchain itself to act as the primary securities document. However, the proposal does not imply that tokenized securities will be completely 'permissionless.' Joris Delanoue, CEO of the SEC-registered on-chain transfer agent Fairmint, pointed out that while the blockchain can remain open, assets must still comply with ownership and transfer rules, and regulatory controls such as identity verification and transfer restrictions will still be embedded in the tokens. Transfer agents will still need to handle administrative matters such as shareholder death, inheritance, and legal notifications, with processing times potentially reduced from 3-5 days to 1 day. The 60-day public comment period for the proposal will end in early November.

  • SEC Proposes Amendments to Transfer Agent Rules, Allowing Blockchain Ledgers as Official Securities Ownership Records

    On September 11, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) proposed a new rule last week aimed at comprehensively revising the transfer agent rules that have been in place for decades. For the first time, it explicitly allows electronic databases, including blockchain ledgers, to serve as official records of securities ownership. If approved, blockchain is expected to become the 'primary securities document,' replacing the off-chain parallel ownership records that tokenized securities currently rely on. Currently, many tokenized securities operate on two sets of records: an on-chain token ledger and an official shareholder register. Once the proposal is passed, issuers and transfer agents may no longer need to maintain duplicate records and reconcile them after each transfer, thereby reducing operational friction and the risk of inconsistencies between on-chain records and legally recognized records. Eli Cohen, Chief Legal Officer of the tokenized fund platform Centrifuge, stated that the proposal could transform the current 'two-step' process into a 'one-step' process, allowing the blockchain itself to serve as the primary securities document. However, the proposal does not mean that tokenized securities will be completely 'permissionless.' Joris Delanoue, CEO of Fairmint, a registered on-chain transfer agent, pointed out that while the blockchain can remain open, assets must still comply with ownership and transfer rules, and regulatory controls such as identity verification and transfer restrictions will still be embedded in the tokens. Transfer agents will still need to handle administrative matters such as shareholder death, inheritance, and legal notifications, with processing times potentially reduced from 3-5 days to 1 day. The 60-day public comment period for the proposal will end in early November.

  • Coinbase Renames Base App to Coinbase Wallet

    On September 11, Coinbase announced that it has renamed the Base App back to Coinbase Wallet, reversing the decision made a year ago. The focus of the self-custody application is shifting towards trading and broader multi-chain access. Ryan Kass, the product lead for Coinbase Wallet, stated that the wallet will serve as a 'test kitchen' for products and assets not yet offered by the centralized exchange Coinbase, with the first case being perpetual contracts supported by Hyperliquid. The wallet also supports long-tail assets and plans to gradually integrate new chains as they launch. Additionally, the wallet supports prediction markets and tokenized stocks. Coinbase indicated that the Base App has evolved into a broader multi-chain trading platform, making the restoration of the Coinbase Wallet name a reasonable decision. The wallet is promoted with the selling points of 'no KYC, no waiting, and no borders,' allowing users to start trading within minutes after downloading the app, although some features remain region-restricted. The wallet will automatically detect and hide scam or malicious tokens, and new markets and asset classes must undergo rigorous product and compliance reviews before launch. In terms of background, Coinbase renamed Coinbase Wallet to Base App in July 2025, positioning it as a 'universal app' that integrates social features, mini-apps, messaging, payments, and trading. CEO Brian Armstrong acknowledged in March this year that the social experiment was 'not very successful,' after which Base founder Jesse Pollak handed over leadership of the app to Jordan 'Cobie' Fish.

  • Coinbase Renames Base App to Coinbase Wallet

    On September 11, Coinbase announced the renaming of Base App to Coinbase Wallet, reversing the decision made a year ago and shifting the focus of the self-custody application towards trading and broader multi-chain access. Ryan Kass, the product lead for Coinbase Wallet, stated that the wallet will serve as a 'test kitchen' for products and assets not yet offered by the centralized exchange. The first case is a perpetual contract supported by Hyperliquid, and the wallet will also support long-tail assets, with plans to gradually integrate new chains as they launch. The wallet also supports prediction markets and tokenized stocks. Coinbase indicated that the Base App has evolved into a broader multi-chain trading platform, making the restoration of the Coinbase Wallet name a logical move. The wallet is promoted with the selling points of 'no KYC, no waiting, no borders,' allowing users to start trading within minutes after downloading the app, although some features remain regionally restricted. The wallet will automatically detect and hide fraudulent or malicious tokens, and new markets and asset classes must undergo rigorous product and compliance reviews before launch. In the background, Coinbase renamed Coinbase Wallet to Base App in July 2025, positioning it as a 'universal app' that integrates social, mini-apps, messaging, payments, and trading. CEO Brian Armstrong acknowledged in March this year that the social experiment was 'not very successful,' after which Base founder Jesse Pollak handed over the leadership of the app to Jordan 'Cobie' Fish.

  • BTC Falls Below $77,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $77,000, currently priced at $76,970, with a 24-hour decline of 3.24%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • BTC Falls Below $77,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $77,000, currently priced at $76,970, with a 24-hour decline of 3.24%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • BTC Falls Below $78,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $78,000, currently priced at $77,996.97, with a 24-hour decline of 1.61%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • BTC Falls Below $78,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $78,000, currently priced at $77,996.97, with a 24-hour decline of 1.61%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • US Spot Bitcoin ETF Sees Net Outflow of $120.2 Million Yesterday

    On September 10, according to monitoring data from Farside Investors, the US spot Bitcoin ETF experienced a net outflow of $120.2 million yesterday.

  • US Spot Bitcoin ETF Sees Net Outflow of $120.2 Million Yesterday

    On September 10, according to monitoring data from Farside Investors, the US spot Bitcoin ETF experienced a net outflow of $120.2 million yesterday.