Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Exploring the Nuances of Address Poisoning

Validated Media

The world of crypto-crime is ever-evolving and just a month into 2023, a new crypto scam is on the rise. Known primarily as address poisoning, but also referred to as address spoofing, this scam has already prompted a consumer alert from a major cryptocurrency wallet, MetaMask, to its users on Twitter.

According to MetaMask, after a customer sends a normal transaction a scammer will send them a token transaction worth nothing or a nominal value, effectively “poisoning” or tainting the entire transaction history. Instead of using a normal wallet address that is automatically generated, the attacker will use a custom-made vanity address closely resembling the one belonging to the user. Attackers often duplicate four or five of the beginning and ending characters using an open-source tool like Profanity. The attacker is hoping that the user will mistakenly copy their vanity address, instead of the user’s actual address, for future transactions.

How Do Address Poisoning Scams Work?

The address poisoning scam works as follows.

First, attackers monitor the blockchain to look for regularly active wallet addresses. By doing so, they can generate a shortlist of addresses to attack - sparing them the hassle of attacking dead, dormant, or secondary wallet addresses. Targeting addresses in this way is critical as the marginal cost of each attack isn’t zero, as attackers still have to pay network fees when spoofing an address.

These scammers rely on the fact that it is not practical for people to memorize a wallet address. Variably composed of either alphanumeric characters as in the case of BTC or hexadecimal characters as in the case of ETH (which generates them cryptographically), they are typically very long. A Bitcoin wallet address, for example, ranges from 26 to 35 characters, while a MetaMask wallet address is 42 characters.

Given how difficult it is to commit a full address to memory, people rely on mental shortcuts for validation. For instance, someone may only scan the first and last letters of an address to check if it’s correct. Using this technique, it would be hard to differentiate between:

0xC660DC4250C4F07cF780cBf0c897nHQPLN123Bn0 (a hypothetical user address)

and

0xC660EL1NDZK8L69cP9LKdRZNd213wPOX9T523Bn0 (a spoofed vanity address)

It may be easy for you to distinguish the two addresses because you have been primed to find a difference, but to someone rushing to complete a transaction, they may seem close enough to avoid drawing suspicion.

Because users cannot remember addresses in their entirety, the scammer can easily create similar-looking vanity addresses to fool users. In practice, it’s very similar to how cyber criminals spoof banking websites like Wells Fargo hoping to capture unsuspecting victims’ login credentials.

Second, scammers then execute the process of poisoning or modifying a person’s transaction history by sending them a very small or negligible amount of cryptocurrency.

Third and finally, users then copy and paste the address from their transaction history when it’s needed for other transactions. If a user is unknowingly copying and pasting a poisoned address, it may be a while before the user even notices that something is wrong. Funds may be inadvertently sent to the spoofed address on multiple occasions.

Unfortunately, there’s no complex explanation for why this happens: people are lazy. Rather than grab their wallet address from its address book, they will grab it from where it is most readily available, which is commonly their transaction history. The poisoning scam succeeds because it takes advantage of human psychology and behavior, which indicates that people will follow the most convenient path.

While MetaMask may be the biggest brand to warn about address spoofing, it is not alone. Ledger, which manufactures hardware wallets, also noted the rise of this scam. While Ledger gave advice on how to prevent falling victim to address poisoning with any Ledger product, they noted that the scam could happen on any blockchain. It theorized that attackers would prioritize blockchains where network fees are cheap, such as Polygon, Tron, or Binance.

Some platforms may even be unintentionally facilitating this scam. To improve their user experience, some platforms and wallets provide wallet address shorteners that visibly compress the address in some way, such as by only showing the first five and last five characters. This feature increases the chance of address poisoning succeeding. Instead of relying on users to overlook the middle characters, a vanity address and a shortened address can now appear indistinguishable from one another. With the advent of address poisoning, any wallet or platform that offers address shortening should consider discontinuing the feature to better protect users from scammers.

How Can We Prevent Address Poisoning from Succeeding?

To best combat the rise of address poisoning across wallets and blockchains, it’s important to distinguish this scam from similar schemes, such as dusting attacks. As with address poisoning, a dusting attack relies on sending a negligible amount of cryptocurrency to different wallet addresses. But this is where the resemblance ends, and the goals diverge. The intent of address poisoning is to mimic the person’s address so that the conflation of wallet addresses results in funds mistakenly being sent to the poisoned address. The purpose behind a dusting attack is almost the opposite: de-anonymizing the recipient by watching how funds are spent, so they can possibly be identified. Once identified, the attackers may escalate the attack by blackmailing the de-anonymized user, trying to extort them, or targeting them for phishing.

Address poisoning more closely resembles a common variation of spear phishing, a scam where attackers create similar-looking email addresses to one that the target regularly works with. If the target uses [email protected], the attacker may send an email from the address [email protected], much, in the same way, crypto scammers create vanity addresses. From there, the spear phisher will send an email requesting payment for overdue services and provide a bank account. The method of both address poisoning and spear phishing is nearly one and the same: combine people’s carelessness with digital mimicry so funds end up in the wrong hands.

As with spear phishing, there are several ways to combat address poisoning, which have already made the rounds amidst these early warnings.

  • Double-check the address. If the user has a known location where they previously stored the wallet address, such as an offline document, they can double-check that every character matches. While this cross-referencing may be accurate, it can be tedious.
  • Source the original address. This will be product-specific, but there should be a location where users can access their addresses. On Ledger, users are encouraged to refer to the address on the receive button in “Ledger Live” on their Ledger device - if the addresses do not match, users are advised to cancel the transaction. For other software or hardware wallets, users should consult the documentation to ensure they are getting the wallet address from the correct location.
  • Use an address book. On MetaMask, users can input and confirm a specific address through the Address Book feature, which cannot be changed by any attackers attempting address poisoning. Most major wallets, such as Binance and Coinbase also offer this feature, which users should take advantage of.
  • Keep funds in a cold wallet or hardware wallet. Users can also elect to keep some of their cryptocurrency in a cold wallet, as suggested by Binance. Cold wallet storage can even be paired with a test transaction, whereby a user sends a small amount and waits for it to be confirmed, before executing the full transaction. The caveat is that there have been some reports of cold wallets also falling victim to address poisoning. Another option is the use of a hardware wallet, which are devices that secure a user’s keys offline. Because any transaction must be signed with the private keys that match the wallet, it would be nearly impossible to send funds to the wrong wallet as part of an address-poisoning scam.
  • Leverage forensic analysis. Just as proof-of-reserve emerged as an innovation to prove whether exchanges really have ownership over said funds, other cryptographic or forensic techniques may arise that combat address poisoning. Some methods may include the ability to better track the creation of the vanity addresses at the center of these scams and the flow of funds in and out of any associated wallets.

The story around address spoofing is still developing, and if you’re interested in seeing how this develops please look out for our next piece in the address spoofing series, as well as in our upcoming Hackhub report. Stay tuned until then and watch your wallet addresses closely!

Read more: https://blog.merklescience.com/general/exploring-the-nuances-of-address-poisoning?

Get the latest news here: Cointime channel — https://t.me/cointime_en

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Putin States Negotiations with Ukraine Currently Impossible

    On October 10, Russian presidential aide Ushakov provided details about the phone call between the leaders of Russia and the United States. Ushakov stated that during the call, Putin elaborated on the measures Russia has taken in response to the terrorist attacks carried out by the Ukrainian armed forces. Putin indicated that Ukraine is attempting to undermine the Russian State Duma elections and is attacking civilians, which has compromised the possibility of immediately resuming negotiations. He also noted that Ukraine's attempts to hinder the advance of Russian troops have no prospects for success, as the Russian military currently holds complete initiative on the battlefield and is continuing to advance. Putin emphasized that due to Ukraine's stance, particularly its efforts to disrupt the Russian Duma elections, it is currently impossible to resume negotiations with Ukraine. Trump has instructed that the message conveyed by Putin during the call be communicated to the Ukrainian delegation. Ushakov mentioned that there has been no specific discussion yet regarding a potential bilateral meeting between Putin and Trump.

  • Telegram Renames Gram Wallet to Money and Launches for All Users

    On October 9, Telegram officially renamed its previously limited-access wallet service 'Gram wallet' to 'Money' and launched it to over one billion users across the platform. 'Money' is an integrated wallet for the Gram token, supporting storage, transfers, and purchases of platform gifts and collectible usernames. Additionally, the accompanying trading platform 'Walt' offers services for over 300 assets, including tokenized stocks, precious metals, perpetual contracts, and wealth management projects. Users can make instant transfers from 'Walt' to the 'Money' wallet without incurring network fees. The official statement also cautions that investing in crypto assets carries associated risks.

  • Blockchain.com Seeks Approval for Prediction Markets and Cryptocurrency Derivatives Trading

    On October 9, the crypto asset platform Blockchain.com submitted an application to the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) seeking to obtain licenses for a designated contract market (DCM) and a futures commission merchant (FCM) to offer event contracts (prediction markets) and cryptocurrency derivatives trading services to U.S. users.

  • US May Seize Approximately $1 Billion in Cryptocurrency Related to Iran This Week

    U.S. Treasury Secretary Bencet stated at the NPolicy Summit held by Newsmax in Washington on Thursday that we may seize $1 billion in cryptocurrency this week, adding, "We know where it is, and we are isolating them." Bencet noted that the Trump administration's approach to Iran has shifted from 'maximum pressure' to 'absolute isolation,' with measures including maritime blockades, restrictions on air travel, and the cutting off of land routes. The UAE and Oman are cooperating with the U.S., which is also working with Pakistan and Turkey to cut off all land routes in and out of Iran.

  • Zcash Development Team Plans to Introduce Quantum-Resistant Signatures in January

    The development team of the privacy cryptocurrency Zcash (ZEC) plans to introduce post-quantum signature opcodes to the network in January next year, supporting hash-based signature technology to defend against potential quantum computing attacks. This solution primarily targets the transparent (public) payment pool, where approximately 70% of ZEC is currently stored. Although the developers have set January as the target deadline, the specific network activation time has not yet been finalized. This upgrade aims to prevent attackers from using existing public keys to reverse-engineer private keys and forge payment authorizations. Additionally, the Zcash node validator Zakura has launched a wallet tool based on Private Information Retrieval (PIR), allowing users to query balances across multiple addresses without revealing the correlation between those addresses to the server. Previously, Ethereum researcher Justin Drake warned that artificial intelligence could accelerate the cracking of traditional encryption algorithms and urged cryptocurrency holders to prepare for potential security threats.

  • BTC Surpasses $83,000

    Market data shows that BTC has surpassed $83,000, currently priced at $83,017.3, with a 24-hour increase of 0.66%. The market is highly volatile, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • Central Committee and State Council: Comprehensive Implementation of 'AI+' Initiative

    On October 9, the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China and the State Council issued the 'Opinions on Developing New Quality Productive Forces.' The opinions mention the comprehensive implementation of the 'AI+' initiative. This includes promoting the transformation of traditional industries through artificial intelligence, accelerating the development of new-generation intelligent terminal applications such as smart connected new energy vehicles, AI smartphones and computers, and humanoid robots. It aims to speed up innovation in digital intelligence technologies like artificial intelligence, break through foundational theories and core technologies, and strengthen the efficient supply of computing power, algorithms, and data. The strategy involves tailored approaches based on local conditions and industry-specific policies to layout national pilot bases for AI industry applications and high-value application scenarios, vigorously promoting the application of AI across various sectors. Additionally, it emphasizes the establishment of a technology monitoring, risk warning, and emergency response system to ensure that artificial intelligence is safe, reliable, and controllable.

  • U.S. Government-Related Wallet Deposits 17,733 BTC and 750 WBTC to Coinbase Prime

    On October 9, according to monitoring by Lookonchain, wallets associated with the U.S. government have deposited 17,733 BTC (worth $1.48 billion) and 750 WBTC (worth $62 million) into Coinbase Prime over the past three days. According to tagging data from Arkham, these wallets currently hold cryptocurrency assets valued at $25.4 billion, with Bitcoin alone valued at $25.3 billion.

  • ETH Falls Below $2500

    Market data shows that ETH has fallen below $2500, currently priced at $2499.87, with a 24-hour decline of 2.55%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • ETH Surpasses $2500

    Market data shows that ETH has surpassed $2500, currently priced at $2500.13, with a 24-hour decline of 2.21%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.