Download App
iOS & Android

Grayscale ETH futures ETF a ‘trojan horse’ for spot Ethereum ETF: Analyst

Validated Media

Grayscale Investments is using its Ether futures exchange-traded fund (ETF) application as a “trojan horse” to corner the United States Securities and Exchange Commission into approving its spot Ether ETF, says Bloomberg ETF analyst James Seyffart.

Seyffart said in a Nov. 15 X (Twitter) post following the SEC delaying Grayscale’s ETH futures ETF bid that he believes if the SEC approves Grayscale’s application, then it would enable Grayscale to argue for the approval of its spot Ether ETF application.

If the SEC denies Grayscale’s bid, the asset manager could argue the SEC is treating Bitcoin and Ether futures ETFs differently by allowing one under the Securities Act of 1933 but not the other.“Watch [the SEC] try to either approve and argue why this is different from spot. Or Deny and argue why 1933 act products are meaningfully different from 1940 act products. Both are bad for SEC [in my opinion]. Genius move.”

Grayscale’s Ether futures ETF bid was submitted via a form 19b-4 — which exchanges file to inform the SEC of a security-based swap request. Seyffart said none of the 40 or so approved Ether ETF products went through the 19b-4 approval process.

Seyffart was initially unsure why Grayscale filed its Ether futures ETF via a 19b-4. He now believes Grayscale is playing “chess” with the SEC by using the Ether Futures ETF as a “trojan horse” to obtain a 19b-4 order from the regulator to corner them into a lose-lose situation.

Seyffart and Scott Johnsson, General President at Van Buren Capital General, agreed Grayscale wouldn’t launch the Ether futures ETF.

“Doubtful this product ever trades, but useful as a vessel to get spot ETH over the finish line,” Johnsson said.

Seyffart’s comments come as the SEC delayed its decision on Grayscale’s Ether futures ETF on Nov. 15 — two days earlier than its Nov. 17 deadline. Seyffart said he wasn’t surprised by the delay.

Hashdex’s application to convert its Bitcoin futures exchange-traded fund (ETF) into a spot product was also put on hold by the securities regulator on Nov. 15.

BlackRock shared a similar sentiment to Seyffart last week, arguing that the SEC doesn't have a legitimate reason to treat cryptocurrency spot and futures ETF applications differently.


All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Tevaera Closes $5 Million Funding Round to Create One-Stop Gaming Ecosystem Powered by zkSync's ZK Stack

    Tevaera, a gaming platform powered by zkSync's ZK Stack, has closed a $5 million funding round led by Laser Digital and Nomura Group. The funding will support Tevaera's mission to create a one-stop gaming ecosystem. The project has attracted prominent investors, including Hashkey Capital, Fenbushi Capital, and Capital. Tevaera has also launched a redesigned website and is preparing to introduce two new games and the first decentralized L3 gaming chain on zkSync.

  • The Hong Kong Securities Regulatory Commission’s official website has listed the Bitcoin and Ethereum spot ETFs and stock codes of China Asset Management, Bosera and Harvest.

    Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission website has listed the Bitcoin and Ethereum spot ETFs of three fund companies, Huaxia, Boshi, and Jiashi, with approval dates all on April 23, 2024. The related funds are not derivative product funds, specifically including:1. Huaxia Bitcoin ETF (BUU163) with share codes of 03042, 09042, and 83042;2. Huaxia Ethereum ETF (BUU164) with share codes of 03046, 09046, and 83046;3. Boshi HashKey Bitcoin ETF (BUU104) with share codes of 03008 and 09008;4. Boshi HashKey Ethereum ETF (BUU105) with share codes of 03009 and 09009;5. Jiashi Bitcoin Spot ETF (BUT244) with share codes of 03439 and 09439;6. Jiashi Ethereum Spot ETF (BUU885) with share codes of 03179 and 09179.

  • Correction: Nigeria’s central bank says “freezing Bybit, KuCoin, OKX, Binance user accounts” is unofficial

    The official X account of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) stated that the announcement "the Central Bank of Nigeria will freeze Bybit, KuCoin, OKX, and Binance user accounts" is not an official release. Previously, according to Cointelegraph, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) issued an instruction requiring all banks and financial institutions to identify individuals or entities trading with cryptocurrency exchanges and ensure that such accounts receive no debit (PND) instructions within six months.

  • Alliance of 314: The X314 contract is suspected to have a hidden additional issuance switch, developers should pay attention to verification

    Alliance of 314 issued a statement claiming that the contract of a certain 314 project has not been open-sourced on the blockchain. As for whether other platforms have open-sourced their contracts, there is a misconception that open-sourcing on other platforms is self-submitted and does not necessarily mean that the contract is deployed on the chain, so there may be unknown hidden issuance. Additionally, the said 314 project announced that it will soon launch a trading platform, and the first requirement for logging into a centralized exchange is to open-source the contract. Open-sourcing is the first thing that any project should do to ensure investor confidence. Referring to the open-sourcing of the 0.1, 0.5, and 0.9 versions before, it can be concluded that there is hidden code in the X314 contract, and therefore it cannot be open-sourced out of fear. The biggest risk warning: after decompiling and querying ethervm, it is highly suspected that a certain 314 has a hidden issuance switch to increase mining pool output and arbitrage. The field is as follows: 0x40c10f19mint(address,uint256). The risk alert level for this switch is the highest level, and generally, ordinary developers do not set this switch.

  • Left Curve

    Some of you think you are masters of the universe right now because you bought Solana sub $10 and sold it at $200. Others did the smart thing and sold fiat for crypto during the 2021 to 2023 bear market but lightened up as prices surged in the first quarter of this year. If you sold shitcoins for Bitcoin, you get a pass. Bitcoin is the hardest money ever created. If you sold shitcoins for fiat that you don’t immediately need for living expenses, you are fucking up. Fiat will continue to be printed ad infinitum until the system resets.

  • Binance Founder Faces Potential Three-Year Prison Sentence and $50 Million Fine for Money Laundering and Sanctions Violations

    Binance founder Changpeng Zhao has been recommended a three-year prison sentence by federal prosecutors for violating federal money laundering laws and sanctions. The Department of Justice argued that this sentence would hold him accountable for his intentional criminal conduct and send a message to the world. Zhao made a "business decision" to break the law to attract users, build his company, and line his pockets, according to prosecutors. Along with the prison sentence, DOJ lawyers also requested that Zhao pay the $50 million fine he agreed to as part of a plea deal. Zhao, who is a citizen of the UAE and Canada, has been released on a $175 million bond but must remain in the U.S. until his sentencing on April 30.

  • Market News: South Africa authorizes 75 companies as cryptocurrency service providers

    According to Jinshi news, South Africa has authorized 75 companies as cryptocurrency service providers.

  • Indonesian President: $8.6 billion laundered through cryptocurrency in 2021

    According to Golden Finance News, Indonesian President Joko Widodo stated that he has noticed signs of money laundering through cryptocurrency in 2021, amounting to $8.6 billion (IDR 139 trillion). In addition to cryptocurrencies and NFTs, the president emphasized the need to monitor other potential money laundering tools, including virtual assets, market activities, e-currencies, and AI-driven transactions. Mahendra Siregar, Chairman of the Financial Services Authority (OJK) Committee, responded to the President's directive, stating that when cryptocurrency regulation is transferred to the OJK next year, his agency will supervise these issues.

  • BTC breaks through $67,000

    Tthe market shows that BTC has broken through $67,000 and is now trading at $67,025.99, with a daily increase of 1.12%. The market is volatile, please be prepared for risk control.

  • Bitcoin spot ETF had a total net inflow of $31.6354 million yesterday, and the ETF net asset ratio reached 4.27%

    According to SoSoValue data, the total net inflow of Bitcoin spot ETF was $31.6354 million on April 23 (US Eastern Time).Grayscale ETF GBTC had a net outflow of $66.8838 million on April 23, and the historical net outflow of GBTC is $16.833 billion.The Bitcoin spot ETF with the highest net inflow on April 23 was BlackRock ETF IBIT, with a net inflow of $37.9233 million in a single day, and the historical total net inflow of IBIT has reached $15.479 billion.The second highest was the ARKB ETF from Ark Invest and 21Shares, with a net inflow of $33.282 million in a single day, and the historical total net inflow of ARKB has reached $2.267 billion.As of now, the total net asset value of Bitcoin spot ETF is $55.82 billion, and the ETF net asset ratio (the proportion of market value to the total market value of Bitcoin) is 4.27%, with a historical cumulative net inflow of $12.416 billion.