Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Grayscale ETH futures ETF a ‘trojan horse’ for spot Ethereum ETF: Analyst

Validated Media

Grayscale Investments is using its Ether futures exchange-traded fund (ETF) application as a “trojan horse” to corner the United States Securities and Exchange Commission into approving its spot Ether ETF, says Bloomberg ETF analyst James Seyffart.

Seyffart said in a Nov. 15 X (Twitter) post following the SEC delaying Grayscale’s ETH futures ETF bid that he believes if the SEC approves Grayscale’s application, then it would enable Grayscale to argue for the approval of its spot Ether ETF application.

If the SEC denies Grayscale’s bid, the asset manager could argue the SEC is treating Bitcoin and Ether futures ETFs differently by allowing one under the Securities Act of 1933 but not the other.“Watch [the SEC] try to either approve and argue why this is different from spot. Or Deny and argue why 1933 act products are meaningfully different from 1940 act products. Both are bad for SEC [in my opinion]. Genius move.”

Grayscale’s Ether futures ETF bid was submitted via a form 19b-4 — which exchanges file to inform the SEC of a security-based swap request. Seyffart said none of the 40 or so approved Ether ETF products went through the 19b-4 approval process.

Seyffart was initially unsure why Grayscale filed its Ether futures ETF via a 19b-4. He now believes Grayscale is playing “chess” with the SEC by using the Ether Futures ETF as a “trojan horse” to obtain a 19b-4 order from the regulator to corner them into a lose-lose situation.

Seyffart and Scott Johnsson, General President at Van Buren Capital General, agreed Grayscale wouldn’t launch the Ether futures ETF.

“Doubtful this product ever trades, but useful as a vessel to get spot ETH over the finish line,” Johnsson said.

Seyffart’s comments come as the SEC delayed its decision on Grayscale’s Ether futures ETF on Nov. 15 — two days earlier than its Nov. 17 deadline. Seyffart said he wasn’t surprised by the delay.

Hashdex’s application to convert its Bitcoin futures exchange-traded fund (ETF) into a spot product was also put on hold by the securities regulator on Nov. 15.

BlackRock shared a similar sentiment to Seyffart last week, arguing that the SEC doesn't have a legitimate reason to treat cryptocurrency spot and futures ETF applications differently.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Michael Saylor Releases Bitcoin Tracker Update

    On October 4, Michael Saylor, founder and executive chairman of Bitcoin treasury company Strategy, once again released information related to the Bitcoin Tracker, captioned 'More orange than ever.' According to previous patterns, Strategy typically discloses changes in Bitcoin holdings the day after such announcements.

  • Iran Responds to U.S. Proposal

    On October 4, an Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesperson stated that Iran has responded to the U.S. proposal. The U.S. proposal is similar to previous ones, focusing on nuclear issues, while Iran wishes to emphasize the Strait of Hormuz.

  • Tom Lee: The Current Crypto Bull Market Has Begun, Tokenization and AI Applications May Drive Growth Beyond Previous Cycles

    Tom Lee, Chief Investment Officer at Fundstrat, explained in an interview why the current crypto bull market is different from previous cycles. He stated, "The cryptocurrency bull market that is beginning has been confirmed. As of the third quarter, cryptocurrency-related stocks are undoubtedly the best-performing assets." Discussing the differences in this cycle, he noted: "The 2016-2017 cycle had ICOs; the cycle during the COVID-19 pandemic featured NFTs and meme coins; last year's minor cycle involved stablecoins. These all belong to relatively narrow application scenarios, and the participants were mainly those who returned to the crypto industry after previous losses." Regarding the changes in this cycle, he said: "Tokenization will develop on a very large scale; the regulatory environment is becoming more supportive of the crypto industry; the government is also providing support; meanwhile, AI, intelligent agent systems, and related applications are being built around the crypto industry. This means a much larger user base will be involved." On the current market environment, he remarked: "The market has undergone significant price consolidation, in some cases lasting up to five years. With the arrival of this bull market, not only will there be decisive breakthroughs, but its duration and growth potential will far exceed previous cycles."

  • BTC Surpasses $85,000

    Market data shows that BTC has surpassed $85,000, currently priced at $85,004.01, with a 24-hour increase of 0.42%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • CFTC Chair Discusses Next Steps for CLARITY Act: Regulators to Continue Issuing New Crypto Regulations

    On October 4, WOLF Terminal reported that Michael Selig, Chairman of the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), discussed the follow-up work on the CLARITY Act: "Regulatory agencies already possess a significant amount of existing statutory authority. While working with the Presidential Working Group on Digital Assets, we also examined the statutory and legislative powers. The report includes an entire chapter dedicated to explaining how to utilize our existing regulatory authority." Regarding the current regulatory landscape: "The President has a plan in place, and we are prepared. The time for action has come. We will continue to roll out regulatory rules to ensure we are ready for the arrival of new financial sectors."

  • Bitcoin ETF Ends Nine-Day Net Inflow with $148.7 Million Outflow

    On October 1, Farside Investors reported that the Bitcoin ETF experienced a net outflow of $148.7 million yesterday, ending a streak of nine consecutive trading days of net inflows. Additionally, the Ethereum ETF saw a net outflow of $59.6 million yesterday.

  • WTI Crude Oil Drops Over 1.00% Today, Currently at $88.55 per Barrel

    On October 1, WTI crude oil dropped over 1.00% today, currently priced at $88.55 per barrel.

  • Korean Stocks Rise Over 1%

    On October 1, the South Korean Composite Index expanded its gains to 1%, having previously dipped by 1%. In individual stocks, Samsung Electronics rose by 1.12%, and SK Hynix increased by 1.80%. In news, the Korea Customs Service released data on Thursday showing that the export amount for September, adjusted for working days, reached $120.9 billion, setting a new historical high with a year-on-year increase of 104.9%; the total chip exports in September surged by 263% compared to the same period last year, reaching a record $60.3 billion.

  • South Korea to Allow Analysts to Anonymously Publish Reports with 'Sell' Recommendations

    On October 1, South Korea will allow analysts to anonymously publish reports containing 'sell' recommendations.

  • Grayscale's Zcash ETF (ZCSH) Completes 3-for-1 Stock Split

    On October 1, GlobeNewswire reported that Grayscale's Zcash ETF (ticker ZCSH) has completed its previously announced 3-for-1 stock split. The split took effect before the market opened on September 30, with trading occurring on a post-split basis that day. Shareholders recorded as of the close on September 28 received 2 additional shares for every 1 share held, distributed after the close on September 29. This means that each share before the split became 3 shares after the split, with the net asset value (NAV) per share approximately reduced to one-third of its pre-split value, while the total investment value for shareholders remains unchanged. Post-split, ZCSH continues to trade on NYSE Arca, with the CUSIP remaining the same. The filing discloses that ZCSH is an ETP, a fund not registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940, and does not directly hold ZEC.