Download App
iOS & Android

Coinbase’s $3.6M Dutch Fine Shows Crypto Will Hit Road Bumps as It Goes Mainstream

Coinbase’s fine for “very serious” breaches of Dutch crypto registration procedures reveals some of the many pitfalls the industry faces as it works towards operating within the regulatory fold.

The charge sheet from the Dutch central bank (DNB) outlining its decision to impose a sanction of 3,325,000 euros ($3.6 million) for serving local customers without approval shows multiple legal and procedural gray areas – and Coinbase, which is registered with DNB now, argues it is being punished for co-operating.

The size of the fine matches the one imposed on rival crypto exchange Binance last year, and for similar reasons. The DNB argues it’s justified by the gravity and scale of the violation, though Coinbase can still appeal, and may yet do so.

Coinbase originally applied for registration in September 2020 to offer exchange and wallet services – but it withdrew the application a few months later, unable to meet the strictures set by the DNB under an anti-money laundering law which, since 2020, has also applied to crypto.

Registration is a legal requirement to serve the Dutch market, but Coinbase didn’t actually gain the registration until 2022 – during which period it saw huge growth worldwide.

“There was a violation period of almost two years, during which the number of Dutch customers also doubled,” the DNB’s enforcement order said. “DNB therefore regards these violations as very serious.”

“Coinbase, as a globally operating provider of crypto services, should have been aware of the applicable laws and regulations,” it added. “DNB considers that Coinbase's actions are highly culpable.”

The tough stance does not come as a surprise from a country whose officials have been skeptical about retail access to crypto derivatives. The DNB has also issued warnings over KuCoin operating without a registration, and its governor Klaas Knot has hit out at underregulated crypto havens.

In a tweet sent Thursday, Paul Tang, a center-left Dutch member of the European Parliament, said the low level of the fine for selling risky products without a license was a “joke,” comparing the $3 million figure to the billions lost by investors in the crypto crash last year.

A spokesperson for Coinbase told CoinDesk it is still committed to compliance, but disagrees with the fine and is now considering whether to appeal. The company “should not be penalized for playing by the rules,” the spokesperson added, implying the DNB has unfairly targeted those who at least tried to engage with the process, and not those who ignored it entirely.

The document the DNB published on Thursday certainly exposes grounds for disagreement. It cites a “difference of opinion” between crypto providers and the DNB about exactly what verification requirements should apply to crypto wallets, and how far the regulator’s powers extend.

There’s also a dispute about whether Coinbase was offering services in the country at all. The company argued it didn’t have a marketing or ad campaign targeting the population, and that existing European Union rules on financial instrument trading should also apply to crypto marketing by analogy – but the DNB dug out a 2020 business plan that, it says, shows the company was focused on the Dutch market.

Such ambiguities are supposed to be resolved by forthcoming EU rules on the transfer of funds and on crypto asset markets. Those laws are supposed to detail what identity checks wallet providers need to carry out on their customers, and exactly when crypto providers can provide services to EU clients from overseas.

But in the meantime, the DNB fine shows regulators may paper over those gray areas with an approach that is resolutely black-and-white.


All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Meso Raises $9.5M Seed Round for Crypto On-Ramp Platform

    Meso, a Web3 payments platform founded by former PayPal, Braintree and Venmo executives, has raised $9.5 million in a seed round led by Solana Ventures and Rabbit Capital. The fundraising also attracted participation from Canonical Crypto and 6MV, with individual investors including Phantom cofounder Chris Kalani, Pinterest CEO Bill Ready and Bodhi Labs’ Archie Purri. Meso aims to build a crypto payments platform that connects bank accounts with decentralised applications, making it easier for non-crypto native users to buy and sell cryptocurrencies using traditional methods. The company has already partnered with a crypto-friendly regional bank and USDC stablecoin issuer Cross River Bank, and will charge a modest fee of 1.5% for fund transfers between bank accounts and cryptocurrency wallets.

  • US adds Bitcoin and Ethereum addresses linked to LockBit to sanctions list

    The US Treasury Department will add Bitcoin and Ethereum addresses related to LockBit, a Russian ransomware organization, to its sanctions list. The US Treasury Department announced: "This action is our first action in continued cooperation with the US Department of Justice, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, and our international partners against LockBit."

  • Optimism launches the fourth round of airdrops, and more than 10 million OP will be distributed to 23,000 addresses

    On February 21st, Optimism officially announced the launch of the fourth airdrop, distributing a total of 10,343,757.81 OP tokens to 22,998 addresses. The reward criteria are as follows:

  • Grayscale ETF Director: There is a 50% chance that the spot Ethereum ETF will be approved in May

    Dave LaValle, the head of Grayscale ETF, was asked at the annual ETF conference in Miami what the company would do if the SEC refused Grayscale's request to convert its Ethereum Trust into a spot ETF. LaValle said that Grayscale will "have to wait and see" and added that he believes there is a 50% chance of approval in May.

  • Crypto payment platform Meso completes $9.5 million in financing

    The cryptocurrency payment platform Meso has completed a $9.5 million seed round of financing, co-led by Solana Ventures and Ribbit Capital, with participation from Canonical Crypto, 6th Man Ventures, and angel investors including Phantom co-founder Chris Kalani, Pinterest CEO Bill Ready, and Archie Puri of Bodhi Labs.

  • Chain gaming studio Crystal Fun completes US$5 million in seed round financing

    Decentralized blockchain gaming ecosystem and studio Crystal Fun announced the completion of a $5 million seed round of financing. This round of investment was participated by well-known institutions such as Kucoin Ventures, Actoz Soft, Waterdrip Capital, Comma3 Ventures, Stratified Capital, Cypher9 Ventures, Aelf Ventures, W Labs, and Masverse. The funds raised this time will mainly be used for the development and operation of its games. Currently, Crystal Fun has announced the launch of four games: "OUTER", "Endless War", "StarFall", and "Survivor". In addition, Crystal Fun also announced that it will start the second internal testing of the game "OUTER" today, mainly to test the balance values and pressure load in the game to ensure that players can enjoy the best gaming experience.

  • Dalian Securities Regulatory Bureau and other seven departments: Prevent illegal fund-raising in the name of "virtual currency", "Yuanverse", "wealth sharing", etc.

    The Dalian Securities Regulatory Bureau and seven other departments issued a risk warning about preventing illegal fundraising activities under the guise of "virtual currency", "metaverse", "wealth sharing", and other names. Recently, some lawless individuals have used the names of "virtual currency" and "metaverse" to lure investors to download illegal apps and purchase their self-created illegal virtual currency through online WeChat groups and offline national tour meetings, claiming to offer "wealth sharing" opportunities. These activities are suspected of illegal fundraising and fraud, seriously infringing on the property safety of the people and disrupting the order of economic and financial activities.

  • UK ministers expected to introduce legislation on stablecoins and cryptocurrency staking services within six months

    According to Bloomberg, Bim Afolami, the UK Treasury's economic secretary, has stated that the British government is "pushing hard" to legislate on stablecoins and cryptocurrency custodial services within the next six months. In October 2023, the Bank of England and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) announced a wide-ranging plan to coordinate regulation of the cryptocurrency industry.Additionally, according to CoinDesk, the stablecoin rule roadmap indicates that final rules will be discussed by mid-2024 and stablecoin systems will be implemented before 2025.

  • FTX network addresses still hold more than $3 billion worth of token assets

    As of February 20th, FTX currently holds token assets worth $3.158 billion in Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Solana networks, including:

  • Xu Zhengyu: The government believes that it is necessary to bring OTC into supervision

    Hong Kong Financial Secretary and Treasury Bureau Director, Paul Chan Mo-po, stated that the government believes there is a need to regulate over-the-counter (OTC) virtual currency trading platforms and will consult on the proposed regulatory framework in the short term, hoping that citizens and stakeholders will actively express their opinions. We are not sure how short this short term is, but what is certain is that OTC virtual currency trading in Hong Kong will usher in a compliant era. As an old international financial center, Hong Kong has always been relatively open and inclusive in its attitude towards virtual currencies. Hong Kong does not regard virtual currencies as legal tender or financial instruments, but defines them as "virtual assets" and takes corresponding regulatory measures based on the activities and risk levels involved.