Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Can Stablecoins Get Past Their Instability?

By Rajeev Bamra

This post is part of Consensus Magazine’s Trading Week, sponsored by CME. Rajeev Bamra is a senior vice president and head of DeFI and digital assets at Moody’s Investors Service.

Stablecoins, cryptocurrencies designed to hold a stable value through a peg to an underlying asset, such as the U.S. dollar, have gained popularity for their potential to provide the flexibility of cryptocurrency without its price volatility. Their design — whether fiat-backed, as most are, or algorithmic (i.e. backed by other assets or cryptocurrencies) — is meant to offer users a refuge from the price gyrations of traditional cryptocurrencies like bitcoin (BTC) and ether (ETH).

One significant advantage of stablecoins is their operational efficiency and cost-effectiveness in cross-border transactions. Stablecoin transactions can take place with far fewer intermediaries than are involved in traditional bank transfers, for example, making them cheaper and faster to use for sending remittances abroad.

However, although such use cases are promising, stablecoins have not always lived up to their promised stability. In recent years there have been several instances of price depegging, when stablecoins fell below the value of their referenced assets.

See also: USDC Stablecoin Depegs From $1; Circle Says Operations Are Normal

These depegging events have been driven by a range of factors, including regulatory actions, security breaches and imbalances in digital asset pools supporting decentralized exchanges. Investors have responded by divesting their holdings, citing a lack of transparency in underlying reserves and the allure of higher yields from traditional assets in a rising interest rate environment.

Below is a closer look at how several events, as well as changing market conditions, have led to flows away from stablecoins.

  • Terra: risk of unregulated stablecoins. The collapse of the algorithmic stablecoin, UST, on the Terra network in 2022 showcased the risks associated with unregulated stablecoins. The dramatic fall in UST's value had a cascading effect on tether (USDT), the largest stablecoin, causing it to temporarily trade below its $1 peg. UST's reliance on market anticipation and demand for both LUNA and UST left it vulnerable to market fluctuations.
  • FTX: risks from links to traditional finance. The collapse of FTX, a once high-valued centralized crypto exchange, raised concerns about contagion in the industry and led to a decline in USDT's value on major exchanges. These events underscore the interconnection between traditional finance and the cryptocurrency space.
  • Curve and Uniswap: liquidity pool imbalances. Another challenge has been liquidity pool imbalances within decentralized finance (DeFi) platforms, such as Curve Finance and Uniswap. These imbalances, often driven by arbitrage and market fluctuations, have led to deviations from the intended peg of 1:1 for USDT, eroding trust within the DeFi community.
  • Competition from high-yielding, low-risk assets. The inverse correlation between U.S. Treasury yields and stablecoin demand has further complicated the landscape. Rising yields have enticed risk-averse investors to move funds into Treasuries, affecting the market share of stablecoins.

In addition to price volatility and competition from higher-yielding, lower-risk assets like U.S. Treasuries, regulatory ambiguity remains a significant hurdle to expansion of stablecoin usage. The lack of clear regulatory frameworks in the U.S. has left investors cautious and prompted withdrawals from DeFi platforms. The potential adoption of a widely used global stablecoin raises concerns about a shift in purchasing power from sovereign money to private payment services.

See also: How Stablecoins Merge Traditional and Decentralized Finance

STORY CONTINUES BELOW

Recommended for you:

Despite these obstacles, Moody’s believes that stablecoins are likely to play a notable role in a developing digital economy, because they offer an accessible bridge between traditional finance and DeFi. Indeed, some large financial firms are investing in the future of stablecoins. Recently, PayPal introduced an institutional stablecoin, and Visa has extended support for USDC payments within its own operations.

Stablecoins do face competition from more stable alternatives, such as central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) and tokenized bank deposits. However, the demand for stability and security in digital currencies remains. Until these alternatives become widely available, in Moody’s view stablecoins will likely be a significant force in shaping the future of digital money.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Polymarket adds new Olympics category

    Predicting market Polymarket adds "Olympics" category, including:Currently, among the countries predicted to win the most gold medals at the Paris Olympics, the United States accounts for 79% and China accounts for 20%. The amount of the prediction market project has reached 1.2 million US dollars; among the countries predicted to win the most medals, the United States accounts for 94% and China accounts for 6%. The amount of the prediction market project has reached 1.3 million US dollars.

  • Robert Kennedy Jr.'s four Bitcoin policies, including that BTC-USD transactions do not need to be reported or taxed to the IRS

    US presidential candidate Robert Kennedy praised the role that Bitcoin could play in improving the US economy at the Bitcoin 2024 conference. He proposed a comprehensive reform of US monetary policy and added that BTC could restore the US economy to its pre-Nixon era. He promised to issue four executive orders related to Bitcoin if elected:

  • Hong Kong Legislative Council Member Tam Yue-heng: Accelerate the issuance and trading of stablecoins that match the characteristics of the linked exchange rate system

    Tan Yueheng, a member of the National Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference and the Legislative Council, published an article entitled "Consolidating the Status of Financial Center and Sharing the Dividend of Deepening Reform". In it, he pointed out that in the field of digital finance, the SAR government must continue to develop digital finance and qualified virtual products, explore new beneficial financial formats, and promote the new productive forces of the financial industry. Hong Kong must promote the participation of financial technology companies in the stable coin sandbox mechanism, accelerate the issuance and trading of stable coins with the characteristics of matching linked exchange rate system, expand the testing scope and landing scenarios of digital RMB as a cross-border payment tool, and focus on developing products that are linked to virtual assets and underlying real assets, transforming art, real estate, equity, and carbon emissions into digital tokens through blockchain technology.

  • Hong Kong’s virtual asset ETF market has established a mature structure including exchanges, market makers, primary and secondary custodians, etc.

    Wang Long, Chairman of the Greater Bay Area Financial Professionals Association, pointed out in an article published in Ta Kung Pao entitled "Web3.0 Promotes Diversification of Financial Products" that although Hong Kong's ETF market is still in its development stage compared to the United States, it has established a mature architecture, including exchanges, market makers, primary and secondary custodians, etc. The Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission has approved six virtual asset spot ETFs and 14 virtual asset spot ETFs, including Hong Kong dollars, US dollars, and renminbi categories, for trading on platforms holding the Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission license. Nowadays, more and more global investors are paying attention to how to invest in virtual assets, and both the United States and Hong Kong, China have approved the listing of ETF funds for virtual assets, and the investment scale is rapidly increasing.

  • Bloomberg ETF Analyst: XRP ETF may be the next exchange-traded fund product to be launched

    Bloomberg ETF analyst James Seyffart forwarded market news on X platform, stating that during the Bitcoin 2024 conference, Discover Crypto CEO Joshua Jake was interviewed and he said that XRP ETF could be the next possible exchange-traded fund product to launch.

  • Hong Kong's financial industry may study launching stablecoin trading desks and institutional custody services

    Hong Kong Monetary Authority recently announced the list of participants in the stablecoin issuer sandbox, including JD Coin Chain, Circle Coin Innovation, Standard Chartered Bank, Anni Group, Hong Kong Telecom and other institutions. Research reports released by Zeng Shengjun, a researcher at the Greater Bay Area Financial Research Institute of the Shenzhen Branch of Bank of China, and Guan Zhenqiu, a researcher at the Hong Kong Financial Research Institute of Bank of China, analyzed that the Hong Kong dollar stablecoin can improve the efficiency and inclusiveness of the Hong Kong financial system. Its stability, free convertibility, high security, high open source and cross-border mobility can provide support for a wider range of financial innovations.

  • Bitcoin scaling network Mezo completes $7.5 million in financing, led by Ledger Cathay Fund

    Bitcoin scaling network Mezo has completed a $7.5 million financing round, with Ledger Cathay Fund leading the investment and Mantle EcoFund ecosystem projects from ArkStream Capital, Aquarius Fund, Flowdesk, GSR, Origin Protocol, and Bybit participating. This round of financing brings its total funding to $30 million.The new funds will be used for Mezo's plan to expand the adoption of its network, including integrating more products into its network, such as its Bitcoin staking platform Acre.

  • As of July 25, BlackRock IBIT held more than 338,000 bitcoins, an increase of more than 1,092 bitcoins from the previous day.

    BlackRock's official update on the Bitcoin ETF shows that as of July 25th, the market value of IBIT has reached $21,890,121,436.41, and the position has increased to 338,128.5551 BTC, an increase of 1,092.7881 BTC from the previous trading day.

  • The U.S. core PCE price index rose 0.2% in June, compared with expectations of 0.1% and the previous value of 0.10%.

    The US core PCE price index for June was 0.2%, exceeding expectations of 0.1% and the previous value of 0.10%; the US core PCE price index for June recorded a year-on-year increase of 2.6%, higher than expected. The US core PCE price index for June recorded a monthly rate of 0.1%, unchanged from the previous month and in line with expectations.

  • LayerPixel Completes $2 Million Seed Round Led by Kenetic Capital

    LayerPixel, a DeFi solution based on TON, announced the completion of a $2 million seed round of financing, led by Kenetic Capital, with participation from Foresight Ventures, Waterdrip Capital, VentureSouq, Web3 Port Foundation, Microcosm Research, TMM Club, and dozens of angel investors. It is reported that this funding will help LayerPixel accelerate the development and integration of its DeFi solution suite in the Telegram Mini App ecosystem, fundamentally changing the way users interact with decentralized finance in the Telegram environment.