Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

The minimal definition of user agency

So, here’s a provocation from Rabble, who also happened to be a founding engineer at Twitter:

This is a great minimal definition of user agency!

  • Own your ID
  • Own your content
  • Own your contacts

Why do you need all three?

  • If you don’t own your content, you’re stuck. Owning your content is necessary for agency! However, it is not sufficient, because…
  • If you own your content, but don’t own your contacts, then you will lose your entire social graph when you switch services. Network effect will keep you locked in.
  • If you own your content and contacts, but don’t own your ID, you don’t really own anything. Why? IDs are upstream of access. Specifically, this is about who owns your name, and the cryptographic keys that secure your ID, under the hood. If your name is owned by an authority, you lose it if you leave. If your keys are owned by an authority, they are in control. They can lock you out of your stuff, snoop on your private messages, delete your account, or refuse to let you move it elsewhere. So self-sovereign IDs and keys are crucial for agency.

When you own your ID, content, and contacts, you have agency, because you have credible exit. You can seamlessly change services and bring everything important with you, like switching carriers for your mobile phone.

The minimal definition of user agency: own your ID, your content, and your contacts.

User agency is a core goal for us at Subconscious. It’s why we built Noosphere, a protocol for thought.

Noosphere is sort of like “what if Roam/Notion/LogSeq, but a protocol”. A worldwide decentralized thought graph, made up of individual graphs called spheres.

Your sphere is like your inventory on Noosphere. It’s a data structure that contains your content and contacts.

Spheres are published to IPFS, a decentralized network. This decouples your data from any particular app or domain. Your sphere can live anywhere or everywhere at once, and is accessible from any IPFS peer. If a service tries to lock you in, you can always get your content through another node in the decentralized network.

Your sphere is signed with a key that you control. This decouples auth from any particular app or authority. Using your cryptographic key, it’s possible to prove content is secure, no matter where it lives on the network, or what service is hosting it. You own your keys, you own your identity, you own your content.

A decentralized name system ties everything together, keeping your ID portable. In apps and on the web, names are rooted to a particular service, such as facebook.com/alice. If you change services, you lose your name and everything else. On Noosphere, your keys belong to you, and your account name stays the same, no matter where your content happens to live. You can change providers without losing your ID or breaking your links.

With Noosphere, we’re aiming to build a worldwide decentralized repository for thought, belonging to everybody. A decentralized graph, where you own thoughts, and have agency to move your data between services and apps. If that sounds like your jam, come build with us!

GitHub: subconsciousnetwork/noosphereLicense: Apache/MIT

Subconscious is our tool for thought, powered by Noosphere protocol.Sign up for the Subconscious Beta

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • US Spot Bitcoin ETF Sees Net Outflow of $66.71 Million Yesterday

    According to monitoring by Trader T, the US spot Bitcoin ETF experienced a net outflow of $66.71 million yesterday.

  • BTC Surpasses $70,000

    Market data shows that BTC has broken through $70,000, currently trading at $70,011.9. The 24-hour decline has narrowed to 1.11%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please implement risk control measures.

  • BTC Drops Below $69,500

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $69,500, currently trading at $69,492.81. It has experienced a 2.2% decline in the past 24 hours. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please implement risk control measures.

  • CLARITY Act Draft: Ban on Stablecoin Yields for Holding Only

    On March 24, according to CoinDesk, cryptocurrency industry practitioners on Monday saw the latest provisions regarding stablecoin yields in the revised version of the Senate's "Digital Asset Market Clarity Act" for the first time during a closed-door review meeting on Capitol Hill in Washington. The initial impression was that the relevant language was too narrow and lacked clarity. This new provision was released last Friday by Senators Angela Alsobrooks and Thom Tillis. According to a person familiar with the current draft, the new provision will prohibit earning yields solely from holding stablecoins, while restricting any practices that equate such programs with bank deposits, and imposing further limitations on other potentially permissible activities. The specific mechanism for determining activity-based stablecoin rewards remains unclear. This compromise stems from the lobbying battle between the crypto and banking industries. The banking industry insists that stablecoin rewards should not resemble interest-bearing bank deposits, arguing that such competing products could harm the banking sector and stifle lending. The final compromise allows for reward programs based on user stablecoin activities but prohibits balance-based rewards. This closed-door review aims to push the Senate Banking Committee to schedule a hearing, a significant step for the bill towards a full Senate vote. Similar versions of the "Clarity Act" have passed the House of Representatives in previous years, and another version has also passed the Senate Agriculture Committee's markup process. The bill's progress still faces other obstacles: all parties still need to reach an agreement on the DeFi regulatory framework, and Democrats are simultaneously insisting on including provisions that prohibit senior government officials from seeking personal gain from the cryptocurrency industry, a clause clearly targeting President Trump. (Dongxin News Agency)

  • Iran's IRGC: All Vessels Must Coordinate Passage Through Strait

    According to Al Jazeera: The Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) Navy stated that the container ship 'Celine' was forced to leave the area because it did not possess a permit to pass through the Strait of Hormuz. The IRGC Navy further stated that any vessel transiting the Strait of Hormuz must coordinate fully with Iranian maritime authorities. (Jins10)

  • Circle Shares Plunge Over 16%, Hitting Largest Single-Day Drop Since June 2025

    Circle (CRCL) shares fell by more than 16% intraday, marking the largest single-day decline since June 2025. The stock is currently trading at $106.1.

  • BTC Drops Below $70,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $70,000, currently trading at $69,995.57. The cryptocurrency has seen a 1.86% decrease in the last 24 hours, indicating significant price volatility. Investors are advised to manage their risk accordingly.

  • Nasdaq Extends Losses to 1%

    The Nasdaq extended its losses to 1%.

  • Iran Denies Peace Talks Rumors; US Stocks Open Lower

    March 24th news: US stocks opened lower, with the Dow Jones Industrial Average down 0.24%, the S&P 500 index down 0.62%, and the Nasdaq Composite down 0.63%. Li Auto (LI.O) rose 2.8% after announcing a $1 billion share buyback plan. Amazon (AMZN.O) fell 1% following a "service disruption" at its Amazon Web Services (AWS) region in Bahrain. (Jinshi)

  • Tether Hires Big Four Firm for First Full Audit

    On March 24, Tether announced it has engaged one of the Big Four accounting firms to complete its first full audit.