Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Saylor says onchain proof-of-reserves a ‘bad idea’ due to security risks

Michael Saylor, the executive chair of major Bitcoin-buying firm Strategy, formerly MicroStrategy, says institutions posting onchain proof-of-reserves is a “bad idea” that could pose security risks.

“The current, conventional way to publish proof of reserves is an insecure proof of reserves,” Saylor said when asked about institutions adopting the transparency measure at a May 26 event on the sidelines of the Bitcoin 2025 conference in Las Vegas.

“It actually dilutes the security of the issuer, the custodians, the exchanges and the investors. It’s not a good idea, it’s a bad idea.”

Saylor didn’t answer whether Strategy would publish its proof-of-reserves when asked by Blockware Solutions head analyst Mitchell Askew whether his firm would do so.

https://x.com/MitchellHODL/status/1927175496074182798?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1927175496074182798%7Ctwgr%5E81ef239635b33d02a7ec70c20b6ea46a40c361a9%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fcointelegraph.com%2Fnews%2Fmichael-saylor-says-proof-of-reserves-bad-idea

Proof-of-reserves are common among crypto exchanges and verify that the company holds sufficient crypto reserves to cover customer deposits. They can also confirm that other entities, such as crypto-tracking exchange-traded funds, hold the required amount of crypto for the funds.

Saylor acknowledged the industry had a lot to learn from the collapses of crypto exchanges FTX and Mt. Gox, but said proof-of-reserves isn’t the correct measure to take for institutions.

“No institutional-grade or enterprise security analyst would think it’s a good idea to publish all of the wallet addresses, such that you could be traced back and forth.”

“Go to AI, put it in deep think mode and then ask it ‘what are the security problems of publishing your wallet addresses?’ and ‘how might it undermine the security of your company over time,” Saylor said, adding it would write “50 pages of security problems.”

Proof-of-reserves increasingly adopted after FTX collapse

Many crypto exchanges, custodians and exchange-traded fund issuers started publishing their proof-of-reserves following FTX’s collapse in November 2022 to establish transparency and prove that they hold enough assets to back customer deposits.

Related: Strategy bags 4,020 Bitcoin as price briefly breaks $110KCrypto exchanges Binance, Kraken and OKX and crypto asset manager Bitwise are among the industry players that have adopted the transparency measure.However, Saylor noted that proof-of-reserves often only show one side of the picture — what the company holds — and not what they owe.

  Source: Mitchell Askew


Saylor’s Strategy is the world’s largest corporate Bitcoin holder, with 576,230 Bitcoin worth $62.6 million on its balance sheet, followed by Bitcoin mining firm MARA Holdings, which holds 48,137 Bitcoin, according to BitcoinTreasuries.NET.

More than 110 publicly traded companies worldwide have purchased and hold Bitcoin.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • SEC Proposes Amendments to Transfer Agent Rules, Allowing Blockchain Ledgers as Official Records of Securities Ownership

    On September 11, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) proposed a new rule that aims to comprehensively amend the transfer agent rules that have been in place for decades. For the first time, the proposal explicitly allows electronic databases, including blockchain ledgers, to serve as official records of securities ownership. If approved, blockchain could become the 'primary securities document,' replacing the off-chain parallel ownership records that tokenized securities currently rely on. Currently, many tokenized securities operate on two sets of records: an on-chain token ledger and an official shareholder register. Once the proposal is passed, issuers and transfer agents may no longer need to maintain duplicate records and reconcile them after each transfer, thereby reducing operational friction and the risk of inconsistencies between on-chain records and legally recognized records. Eli Cohen, Chief Legal Officer of the tokenized fund platform Centrifuge, stated that this proposal could transform the current 'two-step' process into a 'one-step' process, allowing the blockchain itself to act as the primary securities document. However, the proposal does not imply that tokenized securities will be completely 'permissionless.' Joris Delanoue, CEO of the SEC-registered on-chain transfer agent Fairmint, pointed out that while the blockchain can remain open, assets must still comply with ownership and transfer rules, and regulatory controls such as identity verification and transfer restrictions will still be embedded in the tokens. Transfer agents will still need to handle administrative matters such as shareholder death, inheritance, and legal notifications, with processing times potentially reduced from 3-5 days to 1 day. The 60-day public comment period for the proposal will end in early November.

  • SEC Proposes Amendments to Transfer Agent Rules, Allowing Blockchain Ledgers as Official Securities Ownership Records

    On September 11, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) proposed a new rule last week aimed at comprehensively revising the transfer agent rules that have been in place for decades. For the first time, it explicitly allows electronic databases, including blockchain ledgers, to serve as official records of securities ownership. If approved, blockchain is expected to become the 'primary securities document,' replacing the off-chain parallel ownership records that tokenized securities currently rely on. Currently, many tokenized securities operate on two sets of records: an on-chain token ledger and an official shareholder register. Once the proposal is passed, issuers and transfer agents may no longer need to maintain duplicate records and reconcile them after each transfer, thereby reducing operational friction and the risk of inconsistencies between on-chain records and legally recognized records. Eli Cohen, Chief Legal Officer of the tokenized fund platform Centrifuge, stated that the proposal could transform the current 'two-step' process into a 'one-step' process, allowing the blockchain itself to serve as the primary securities document. However, the proposal does not mean that tokenized securities will be completely 'permissionless.' Joris Delanoue, CEO of Fairmint, a registered on-chain transfer agent, pointed out that while the blockchain can remain open, assets must still comply with ownership and transfer rules, and regulatory controls such as identity verification and transfer restrictions will still be embedded in the tokens. Transfer agents will still need to handle administrative matters such as shareholder death, inheritance, and legal notifications, with processing times potentially reduced from 3-5 days to 1 day. The 60-day public comment period for the proposal will end in early November.

  • Coinbase Renames Base App to Coinbase Wallet

    On September 11, Coinbase announced that it has renamed the Base App back to Coinbase Wallet, reversing the decision made a year ago. The focus of the self-custody application is shifting towards trading and broader multi-chain access. Ryan Kass, the product lead for Coinbase Wallet, stated that the wallet will serve as a 'test kitchen' for products and assets not yet offered by the centralized exchange Coinbase, with the first case being perpetual contracts supported by Hyperliquid. The wallet also supports long-tail assets and plans to gradually integrate new chains as they launch. Additionally, the wallet supports prediction markets and tokenized stocks. Coinbase indicated that the Base App has evolved into a broader multi-chain trading platform, making the restoration of the Coinbase Wallet name a reasonable decision. The wallet is promoted with the selling points of 'no KYC, no waiting, and no borders,' allowing users to start trading within minutes after downloading the app, although some features remain region-restricted. The wallet will automatically detect and hide scam or malicious tokens, and new markets and asset classes must undergo rigorous product and compliance reviews before launch. In terms of background, Coinbase renamed Coinbase Wallet to Base App in July 2025, positioning it as a 'universal app' that integrates social features, mini-apps, messaging, payments, and trading. CEO Brian Armstrong acknowledged in March this year that the social experiment was 'not very successful,' after which Base founder Jesse Pollak handed over leadership of the app to Jordan 'Cobie' Fish.

  • Coinbase Renames Base App to Coinbase Wallet

    On September 11, Coinbase announced the renaming of Base App to Coinbase Wallet, reversing the decision made a year ago and shifting the focus of the self-custody application towards trading and broader multi-chain access. Ryan Kass, the product lead for Coinbase Wallet, stated that the wallet will serve as a 'test kitchen' for products and assets not yet offered by the centralized exchange. The first case is a perpetual contract supported by Hyperliquid, and the wallet will also support long-tail assets, with plans to gradually integrate new chains as they launch. The wallet also supports prediction markets and tokenized stocks. Coinbase indicated that the Base App has evolved into a broader multi-chain trading platform, making the restoration of the Coinbase Wallet name a logical move. The wallet is promoted with the selling points of 'no KYC, no waiting, no borders,' allowing users to start trading within minutes after downloading the app, although some features remain regionally restricted. The wallet will automatically detect and hide fraudulent or malicious tokens, and new markets and asset classes must undergo rigorous product and compliance reviews before launch. In the background, Coinbase renamed Coinbase Wallet to Base App in July 2025, positioning it as a 'universal app' that integrates social, mini-apps, messaging, payments, and trading. CEO Brian Armstrong acknowledged in March this year that the social experiment was 'not very successful,' after which Base founder Jesse Pollak handed over the leadership of the app to Jordan 'Cobie' Fish.

  • BTC Falls Below $77,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $77,000, currently priced at $76,970, with a 24-hour decline of 3.24%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • BTC Falls Below $77,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $77,000, currently priced at $76,970, with a 24-hour decline of 3.24%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • BTC Falls Below $78,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $78,000, currently priced at $77,996.97, with a 24-hour decline of 1.61%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • BTC Falls Below $78,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $78,000, currently priced at $77,996.97, with a 24-hour decline of 1.61%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • US Spot Bitcoin ETF Sees Net Outflow of $120.2 Million Yesterday

    On September 10, according to monitoring data from Farside Investors, the US spot Bitcoin ETF experienced a net outflow of $120.2 million yesterday.

  • US Spot Bitcoin ETF Sees Net Outflow of $120.2 Million Yesterday

    On September 10, according to monitoring data from Farside Investors, the US spot Bitcoin ETF experienced a net outflow of $120.2 million yesterday.