Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Saylor says onchain proof-of-reserves a ‘bad idea’ due to security risks

Michael Saylor, the executive chair of major Bitcoin-buying firm Strategy, formerly MicroStrategy, says institutions posting onchain proof-of-reserves is a “bad idea” that could pose security risks.

“The current, conventional way to publish proof of reserves is an insecure proof of reserves,” Saylor said when asked about institutions adopting the transparency measure at a May 26 event on the sidelines of the Bitcoin 2025 conference in Las Vegas.

“It actually dilutes the security of the issuer, the custodians, the exchanges and the investors. It’s not a good idea, it’s a bad idea.”

Saylor didn’t answer whether Strategy would publish its proof-of-reserves when asked by Blockware Solutions head analyst Mitchell Askew whether his firm would do so.

https://x.com/MitchellHODL/status/1927175496074182798?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1927175496074182798%7Ctwgr%5E81ef239635b33d02a7ec70c20b6ea46a40c361a9%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fcointelegraph.com%2Fnews%2Fmichael-saylor-says-proof-of-reserves-bad-idea

Proof-of-reserves are common among crypto exchanges and verify that the company holds sufficient crypto reserves to cover customer deposits. They can also confirm that other entities, such as crypto-tracking exchange-traded funds, hold the required amount of crypto for the funds.

Saylor acknowledged the industry had a lot to learn from the collapses of crypto exchanges FTX and Mt. Gox, but said proof-of-reserves isn’t the correct measure to take for institutions.

“No institutional-grade or enterprise security analyst would think it’s a good idea to publish all of the wallet addresses, such that you could be traced back and forth.”

“Go to AI, put it in deep think mode and then ask it ‘what are the security problems of publishing your wallet addresses?’ and ‘how might it undermine the security of your company over time,” Saylor said, adding it would write “50 pages of security problems.”

Proof-of-reserves increasingly adopted after FTX collapse

Many crypto exchanges, custodians and exchange-traded fund issuers started publishing their proof-of-reserves following FTX’s collapse in November 2022 to establish transparency and prove that they hold enough assets to back customer deposits.

Related: Strategy bags 4,020 Bitcoin as price briefly breaks $110KCrypto exchanges Binance, Kraken and OKX and crypto asset manager Bitwise are among the industry players that have adopted the transparency measure.However, Saylor noted that proof-of-reserves often only show one side of the picture — what the company holds — and not what they owe.

  Source: Mitchell Askew


Saylor’s Strategy is the world’s largest corporate Bitcoin holder, with 576,230 Bitcoin worth $62.6 million on its balance sheet, followed by Bitcoin mining firm MARA Holdings, which holds 48,137 Bitcoin, according to BitcoinTreasuries.NET.

More than 110 publicly traded companies worldwide have purchased and hold Bitcoin.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Bitcoin miner Core Scientific shifts to AI with 1.5GW data center push

    Core Scientific is converting its Pecos, Texas site into a high-density AI colocation hub, repurposing 300MW of mining capacity.

  • Acting AG Todd Blanche confirms ‘code is not a crime’ in DOJ pivot

    Acting US Attorney General Todd Blanche said developers will no longer be investigated or charged unless they knowingly help third parties commit crimes.

  • Bank of Japan Governor Kazuo Ueda: No Immediate Need for Rate Hike

    On April 28, Bank of Japan Governor Kazuo Ueda stated that there is currently no immediate need to raise interest rates. However, if the current supply shocks lead to secondary ripple effects, a rate hike may be necessary. (Jin Shi)

  • Central Political Bureau Meeting: Comprehensive Implementation of 'AI+' Initiative to Develop New Intelligent Economy and Improve AI Governance

    On April 28, the Central Political Bureau of the Communist Party of China held a meeting to analyze and study the current economic situation and economic work. The meeting emphasized the need to accelerate the construction of a modern industrial system and maintain a reasonable proportion of manufacturing. It called for deepening the construction of a unified national market and addressing 'involutionary' competition. The meeting also announced the comprehensive implementation of the 'AI+' initiative to develop a new intelligent economy and improve AI governance. Furthermore, it highlighted the need to deepen state-owned enterprise reform, systematically respond to external shocks and challenges, enhance the security of energy and resource guarantees, and address various uncertainties with the certainty of high-quality development. (Dongxin News Agency)

  • ByteDance, Zhiyu, and Alibaba Selected Among Top 10 AI Influencers by TIME

    On April 28, TIME announced its list of the '10 Most Influential AI Companies of 2026.' Unlike a simple comparison of model capabilities, this list emphasizes the comprehensive shaping power of companies in terms of industry, technological pathways, and social impact. The selected companies include ByteDance, Amazon, Zhiyu, OpenAI, Alphabet, Meta, Anthropic, Alibaba, Mistral, and Hugging Face. Among them, three are domestic companies: ByteDance, Zhiyu, and Alibaba. (Dongxin News Agency)

  • Arthur Hayes: More Concerned About Fed Nominee Waller's Comments on Balance Sheet Than Short-Term Interest Rates

    On April 28, BitMEX founder Arthur Hayes spoke about the Federal Reserve at the Bitcoin 2026 conference, stating, "When Kevin Waller was nominated as the Fed's SEC chairman, everyone started to panic because during his tenure as a Fed governor— I believe from the 2008 financial crisis until the current president— he has been very critical of the Fed's massive balance sheet. He has publicly stated that he believes the Fed's balance sheet is too large and that he needs to find ways to shrink it while also being able to lower interest rates. Now, if you have read my articles, you know that I am a firm advocate of the idea that the quantity of money is more important than its price. Therefore, I am more concerned about his comments on the balance sheet than the direction of short-term interest rates. So, if the market believes that due to Waller's actions at the Fed, the liquidity of dollars circulating in the system will decrease, then they will be bearish on Bitcoin and other risk assets. This is the discussion we see in the media about a hawkish Fed emerging after Waller takes over in May. Now, I don't think so. I believe that essentially the Fed will replace reserves, treasury bonds, and repos and put them into the commercial banking system, and they will do this with the help of new regulations concerning how banks hold assets on their balance sheets and how much capital they need to hold against those assets. Finally, I think the most important point to understand about what Waller will or will not do at the Fed is that he has a very substantial hard constraint, which is that he needs to work with Treasury's Scott Bessen to ensure that any actions he takes regarding the Fed's balance sheet do not impair Bessen's ability to sell billions and trillions of dollars in bonds.

  • SEC Chair: Reg GG Crypto to Allow Private Sector Token Sales Soon

    On April 28, U.S. SEC Chair Gary Gensler stated in an interview at the Bitcoin 2026 conference that the agency will continue to advance other exciting initiatives, such as truly allowing companies to conduct on-chain experiments, build tokenized securities, and trade on-chain within the United States. We plan to release innovative exemption regulations in the coming weeks. Additionally, we will permit the private sector to raise funds through on-chain token sales, which we refer to as 'Reg GG Crypto.' These initiatives are in preparation and will be launched soon. Currently, there is a bill titled the 'Clarity Act' under consideration in Congress. We do need Congress to provide regulations in this area. We are ready, willing, and able to explain their regulations and translate them into rules that people can rely on and pursue their innovative ideas. It is important to emphasize that this is happening domestically in the U.S., so they do not have to go overseas. This is the core idea that truly matters here.

  • SEC Chair Discusses Clarity Act: Codified Law Provides Greater Assurance for the Future

    On April 28, during the Bitcoin 2026 Conference, SEC Chair Gary Gensler spoke about the Clarity Act, stating that the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has considerable operational flexibility under the regulations. However, we are constrained by existing authorities, which, despite some amendments over the years, fundamentally remain rooted in the framework established in the 1930s. This is why having a piece of legislation is so important; it can shield future developments from adverse impacts, allowing us to leverage new authorities and the flexibility provided by the Act. We can collaborate with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to coordinate and clarify definitions, and further develop from there. But again, nothing provides greater assurance for the future than codified law, coupled with sound judicial opinions that engrave the provisions of the law in stone through the mechanisms of the entire court system. Therefore, all of this is very important, but we are focused on efforts to simplify processes, enhance efficiency, and assist innovators in their endeavors, enabling them to operate with certainty rather than being stifled by those who jealously guard the existing ways of doing things. However, we must ensure that we remain at the forefront of innovation in the United States.

  • Meta Prepares to Withdraw Acquisition of Manus; Investors Including Tencent Plan to Cooperate

    On April 28, the Wall Street Journal reported, citing informed sources, that after the Office of Foreign Investment Security Review under China's National Development and Reform Commission made a legal decision to prohibit foreign investment in the Manus project, Meta is preparing to withdraw from the acquisition deal. According to sources, if Meta proceeds with the withdrawal process, several former Asian investors in Manus, including Tencent, Sequoia China, and ZhenFund, have planned to cooperate.