Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Is PayPal an obstacle behind the rapid rise of cross-border e-commerce in China?

Validated Project

Mr. Zhang, the boss of a Chinese e-commerce company, is in a meeting with his company's finance department to discuss a major crisis his company is facing: a PayPal account he has registered for years has been locked for no reason. The official explanation given by PayPal was that the risk control was triggered, but there was no further explanation.

Based on past experience, such incidents often take weeks or even months to get sorted out. During that time, the account will remain locked and any remaining funds cannot be transferred out. Mr. Zhang was furious and the finance department was confused, but it was clear that no one knew exactly where they had crossed PayPal's red line.

Mr. Zhang's experience was no accident. In the last two years, PayPal has taken a harsher approach to Chinese users as Chinese foreign trade companies have flooded into the U.S. and Europe, seeking to exploit wealth opportunities with cheap supplies and thoughtful service. Accounts registered by Chinese people are more likely to trigger risk controls and be punished by the platform. Increasingly frustrated Chinese merchants have little choice, since it is difficult to set up a bank account in the United States in the first place, and even if they could, complex procedures and tax rules make many start-ups prohibitive.

How did it get so far? On the surface, PayPal is using strict rules to keep consumers in check and prevent online fraud. But in reality, there are not many cases of fraudulent payments made through PayPal, and PayPal's restrictions on Chinese people are more like a territorial protection act.

An American observer may have hit the nail on the head. He noted that the influx of Chinese merchants has disrupted the existing order of the e-commerce industry, and their lower prices have brought benefits to consumers while threatening the profits of local merchants. PayPal's actions are actually on the side of corporate America, and like Amazon's massive blocking of Chinese merchants' accounts, they are rooted in a fear of cheap Chinese goods.

The question is, why would one of the world's leading online third-party payment platforms use its power to oppress specific countries and groups? Who gave them such power?

It's the users themselves. The current mainstream payment platforms are highly centralized architectures. Whether it's PayPal, wechat or Alipay from China, Netcash from Japan or Mollie from Europe, they all have similar interest tendencies and power systems. Mr. Zhang's case is a classic example of the murky rules that platforms often use to play loose with user accounts, data and money whenever their interests clash with those of the platform.

This is the original sin of centralised systems. Unfortunately, the entire Internet of the Web2 era was built on such a system. Hundreds of millions of users around the world have been stuck in the grip of a variety of centralized platforms for the past two decades. Now, China's offshore companies are the new victims.

However, the rise of Web3 has given us a new dawn. The development of blockchain technology has made people realize that decentralized architecture can fundamentally solve the power tyranny of existing platforms. In the field of third-party payment, the rapid rise of PeoplesPay in the past year has provided a large number of merchants and users with truly equal, fair, secure and reliable payment experience for the first time.

PeoplesPay is an international third-party payment service in the form of a convenient and easy-to-use mobile App based on a decentralized architecture. Platform users are not only users, but also service providers. Users have real ownership of their own accounts, data, funds, and even share ownership of the entire platform.

Early movers with a keen sense of smell were quick to see PeoplesPay's potential. In just over a year, PeoplesPay had gained the support of nearly 20,000 merchants, including eBay, Shopee, Rakuten, and handled hundreds of millions of orders. In China, many cross-border e-commerce companies are turning to PeoplesPay to supplement or even replace PayPal services.

Mr. Zhang is one of them. After finally deciding to use PeoplesPay, Mr. Zhang's business has had none of those troubles. Even the number of harassing messages they receive from ads has dropped dramatically. PeoplesPay also helped them reduce transaction rates and foreign exchange costs, which Zhang was very pleased with.

Returning to our original theme: Has PayPal become a barrier to the development of cross-border e-commerce practitioners in China? The answer is clearly yes. Moreover, it is the entire system of centralized payment platforms that has become an obstacle to the Internet's continued vitality and drive for innovation.

PeoplesPay is like a solution from the future. It's still young and has a lot of immaturity. But Mr Zhang thinks that in time it will become the payment giant of the Web3 era, only this time the platform will truly belong to every user.

Maybe the PayPal era is over and we're at the dawn of a revolution.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Zeta Markets Raises $5 Million in Token Funding Round

    Solana DEX Zeta Markets raised $5 million in a new round of funding led by Electric Capital. Other investors in this round of funding include Digital Asset Capital management company, Selini Capital, and Airtree Ventures. Angel investors include Solana's Anatoly Yakovenko, Helius' Mert Mumtaz, Tensor's Richard Wu, Pyth's Genia Mikhalchenko, Wintermute's JMR Luna, and Bonk's Nom also participated in this round of funding.

  • Tornado Cash Developer Alexey Pertsev Sentenced to 64 Months in Prison

    On Tuesday, a Dutch judge ruled that Tornado Cash developer Alexey Pertsev was guilty of money laundering. The court sentenced Pertsev to 64 months in prison. In August 2022, Tornado Cash was blacklisted by the US government, and this is the first time the developer has been sentenced to prison in the Netherlands. At the time, the US Treasury Department claimed that Tornado Cash was a key tool for the North Korean hacker group Lazarus. The Lazarus group is linked to the $625 million hack of Axie Infinity's Ronin Network and other major cryptocurrency thefts.

  • Dutch court finds Tornado Cash founder Alexey Pertsev guilty of money laundering

    A Dutch court composed of three judges has ruled that Tornado Cash developer Alexey Pertsev committed the crime of laundering $1.2 billion in illegal assets on a cryptocurrency mixing platform. It is expected that the panel will also sentence 31-year-old Russian resident Alexey Pertsev on Tuesday, and Pertsev's lawyer will have 14 days to appeal the judge's ruling. Experts say that this ruling will reshape the privacy protection process in the decentralized finance field and have a "chilling effect" on the development of open-source software that provides financial privacy protection tools for users.

  • Cross-border money laundering group laundered HK$88 million, 8 people arrested

    The Hong Kong Police Commercial Crime Bureau locked onto a cross-border money laundering group in November 2023. The investigation found that the group recruited mainlanders to open puppet bank accounts in Hong Kong from September 2023 to March 2024. They used various types of fraud, such as telephone scams, nude chat scams, investment scams, and job scams to defraud victims. The victims were instructed by the fraudsters to deposit the stolen money into the puppet accounts controlled by the criminal group. The group would then withdraw the stolen money from the puppet accounts in cash and buy cryptocurrencies on the over-the-counter (OTC) market. They would also open accounts on overseas cryptocurrency platforms with false identities and deposit the cryptocurrencies purchased with the stolen money before transferring them to multiple cryptocurrency wallets to launder the criminal proceeds. The police also pointed out that the group used 72 local puppet bank accounts to launder more than HKD 88 million in criminal proceeds, of which HKD 6.7 million was related to 48 fraud cases. As of yesterday, the police arrested 7 men and 1 woman aged between 26 and 51 for conspiring to launder black money. They claimed to be a lifeguard, photographer, telephone programmer, salesperson, and unemployed. Six of them were core members, and two were puppet account holders.

  • Sharp Alpha Advisors Raises $25M for Second Fund Targeting Early Stage Software Companies in Sports, Gaming, and Entertainment Industries

    New York-based venture capital firm Sharp Alpha Advisors has secured $25 million for its second fund, which will primarily invest in early stage software companies in the sports, gaming, and entertainment sectors. The fund aims to invest between $1 million and $2 million in 15 startups that fall under the category of "competitive entertainment," such as technology firms catering to sports betting, fantasy sports, streaming platforms, and video games. Sharp Alpha has already invested in London-based technology startup C15 Studio, which operates and distributes streaming channels for Formula 1 and One Championship, and plans to make further investments over the next three to five years. Additionally, the firm has a sidecar vehicle for limited partners to invest more money in individual companies within the fund.

  • Russian authorities plan to impose heavy fines on cryptocurrency miners operating in residential apartments

    Russian authorities have proposed imposing huge fines on cryptocurrency miners suspected of operating in residential properties. The authorities may also consider revising the Code of Administrative Offenses to hold those who abuse electricity accountable.

  • TheoriqAI Completes $6.2 Million Super-Seed Round of Financing, Led by Hack VC

    On May 14th, TheoriqAI, a modular AI agent infrastructure, announced on X platform that it has completed a $6.2 million Super-Seed round of financing. Hack VC led the investment, with participation from Foresight Ventures, HTX Ventures, Figment Capital, HASH CIB, Inception Capital, Antalpha Ventures, NewTribe Capital, Stateless Ventures, Bitscale Capital, Construct Ventures, Hypersphere, IOSG Ventures, LongHash Ventures, HashKey Capital, SNZ Holding, Chainlink.

  • Basel banking regulator delays crypto asset rules for banks until 2026

    The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision's governing body, the Group of Central Bank Governors and Heads of Supervision (GHOS), has delayed the compliance deadline for new rules on bank crypto assets by one year. The latest date for the project has been changed to January 1, 2026.

  • LayerZero CEO: Up to 100,000 addresses have been recognized as witches

    LayerZero CEO Bryan Pellegrino stated on social media that up to 100,000 addresses have been identified as witches. Previously reported on May 4th, LayerZero officials stated that all witch users were given a chance to self-report within the next 14 days and those who did would receive an expected distribution of 15%.

  • Niobium, a fully homomorphic encryption chip provider, completes $5.5 million seed round of financing, led by Fusion Fund

    Niobium, a custom encryption chip provider specializing in zero-trust computing, has announced the completion of a $5.5 million seed round of financing, led by Fusion Fund, with participation from Morgan Creek Capital, Rev1 Ventures, Ohio Innovation Fund, and Hale Capital. It is reported that Niobium is building a fully homomorphic encryption (FHE) accelerator chip and will commercialize it. The new funds will be used to explore the commercial applications of FHE in industries such as healthcare, finance, and blockchain, and also plan to showcase the solution and launch pilot projects in the fourth quarter of this year.