Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

ConsenSys Clears the Air on MetaMask Privacy Policy After Community Backlash

Ethereum infrastructure provider ConsenSys has issued a follow-up statement to its privacy policy update that rattled the MetaMask community last month.

The firm clarified that it does, in fact, collect users’ IP addresses and wallet information when they make a MetaMask transaction through Infura – but plans to reduce its retention of such data down to seven days.

Privacy Concerns at ConsenSys

Per the company’s statement on Tuesday, November’s policy update did not reflect a change in business practices at ConsenSys but rather served to clarify its existing practices. The update revealed that the company’s key products, MetaMask and Infura, collected both users’ wallet and IP addresses, raising privacy concerns.

https://twitter.com/CyphrETH/status/1595722882440642561

“We are committed to protecting the privacy of people who use our products so that they will not—and, ultimately, cannot—be betrayed by yet another centralized entity,” wrote ConsenSys.

Both MetaMask and Infura are pillars of the infrastructure that keeps Ethereum usable today. The former is the smart contract platform’s most widely used software wallet, while the latter is the API and archival node provider used by MetaMask for broadcasting transactions. Infura has also been used by various centralized exchanges like Binance and Bithumb when processing deposits and withdrawals.

As ConsenSys noted, its data collection policy comes with limits. For example, Infura does not store users’ wallet address data for ‘read’ requests, such as checking one’s account balance on MetaMask.

By contrast, wallet and IP data for “write” requests (transactions) are collected “to ensure successful transaction propagation, execution, and other important service functionality such as load balancing and DDoS protection, as provided by Infura.”

Still, ConsenSys said that wallet and IP address information is stored separately so that each piece of data cannot be associated with the other within the company’s systems.

“We have never and will never sell any user data we collect,” it continued.

Infura was one of the node providers to limit access to the privacy protocol Tornado Cash following OFAC’s sanctions against it in August.

Using Other Nodes

To work around the issue entirely, ConsenSys will roll out a new advanced settings page within MetaMask this week that allows wallet users to select their own RPC node provider outside of Infura. While previously possible, this new page will be seen by new users during the onboarding process, allowing them to never use Infura as their server if they so choose.

The company also plans to improve UX around the existing means for changing one’s RPC node, including making steps not to over-caution the user away from doing so.

Nevertheless, ConsenSys did have a certain warning about the practice of using non-default RPC nodes, including self-hosted nodes. “Alternate RPC providers have different privacy policies and data practices, and self-hosting a node may make it even easier for people to associate your Ethereum accounts with your IP address,” it said.

Ethereum archival nodes are recognized by the Ethereum foundation for generally being difficult to run for average users.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • South Korea’s Monetary Authority: Confirmed to include token delisting standards in the Virtual Asset User Protection Act

    The Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) of South Korea has confirmed that token delisting standards will be included in the "Best Practice for Compliance with the Virtual Asset User Protection Act" released in early June. An official from the Financial Supervisory Service stated in a conversation with Bloomberg on Tuesday that the upcoming "Best Practices for Compliance with the Virtual Asset User Protection Act" will not only include listing standards for virtual assets, but also provide guidance on whether to maintain trading of listed virtual assets. The guidance will provide a basis for cryptocurrency issuers to delist in the event of problems. The guidance will be released from the end of May to early June. Currently, the Financial Supervisory Service is developing guidelines to support self-regulation by cryptocurrency exchanges under the Virtual Asset User Protection Act before it is implemented in July. The plan proposes standards for virtual asset issuance, circulation, and trading support, prohibits the listing of virtual assets with a history of hacking attacks, and requires the release of Korean white papers and technical manuals when listing overseas virtual assets.

  • HKEX CEO: Virtual asset exchanges have become HKEX’s competitors

    On May 10th, Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing Limited's new CEO, Nicolas Aguzin, stated in an interview with the Shanghai Securities News that HKEX faces competition not only from other securities exchanges, but also from external competitors such as virtual asset exchanges. In order to meet the rapidly evolving demands of customers and technology, HKEX must balance innovation and stable business operations, continuously expand its resources for listed companies, and improve its market services.

  • WOOFi attacker address has transferred 100 ETH to Tornado cash

    PeckShield monitoring shows that the address marked by the WOOFi attacker has transferred 100 ETH to Tornado cash. The WOOFi attacker has already transferred 2200 ETH (worth about $6.5 million) to Tornado cash.

  • Trump will hold a private dinner on the day of the court recess, inviting NFT trading card buyers to attend

    On May 10th, according to sources, former US President Donald Trump will host a dinner at his Mar-a-Lago estate on a day off, inviting NFT trading card buyers to attend. This event is part of Trump's series of non-campaign activities, aimed at balancing his White House campaign and legal disputes. After Stormy Daniels testified in Trump's trial on Tuesday, Trump expressed his desire for campaigning rather than being tied up in court. Despite no public campaign activities on Wednesday, Trump's schedule includes private political meetings.

  • Tether: Deutsche Bank’s analysis lacks clarity and substantive evidence

    According to a report on stablecoins released on May 7, Deutsche Bank analyzed 334 currencies linked to stablecoins and found that 49% of stablecoins had failed during their median lifespan of about eight to ten years. The analysts concluded that most anchored assets in the cryptocurrency field will experience significant "turbulence" caused by speculative sentiment and ultimately suffer some form of decoupling event. Deutsche Bank analysts also pointed out that Tether's reserve transparency was lacking and described the company's solvency as "doubtful".

  • Yesterday, Solana’s on-chain DEX transaction volume surpassed Ethereum, reaching $1.314 billion

    On May 10th, according to DeFiLlama data, the trading volume of Solana's DEX reached 1.314 billion US dollars yesterday, surpassing the trading volume of 1.297 billion US dollars on Ethereum's DEX.

  • US court orders seizure of 279 virtual currency accounts containing criminal proceeds from North Korean hacking

    A US court has ordered the confiscation of 279 virtual currency accounts containing proceeds from North Korean hacker crimes. US District Court Judge Timothy Kelly in Washington, DC approved the federal prosecutor's request for a summary judgment on these accounts and ordered their confiscation on May 8. This ruling means that these accounts are now under the control of the US Department of Treasury.

  • South Korea’s National Tax Service announced that it would collect 40 billion won in taxes from Bithumb users

    Bithumb has issued a preliminary notice of comprehensive income tax to some users who participated in activities held between 2018 and 2021, and announced full support for the related tax amount. The position of the National Tax Service is that rewards paid to users through various activities (including virtual assets) constitute taxable income. Bithumb does not agree with the National Tax Service's opinion, but explains that taxation is mandatory.

  • The Base ecosystem Bloom project said it has recovered 90% of the funds stolen in the attack

    On May 10th, Bloom, a decentralized derivatives exchange on the X platform, announced that they have recovered $486,000 (minus 10% for bug bounties) out of the total funds utilized ($540,000). All of these funds will be redistributed to limited partners. 10% of the bug bounty has been agreed upon in exchange for not pressing charges against those who exploited the bug. A compensation plan for limited partners affected by the bug will be completed within the next 24-48 hours. Funds are safe and there is currently no need to revoke contract access.

  • US House of Representatives passes SAB 121 crypto rule overturning SEC

    The US House of Representatives has passed H.J. Res. 109, a resolution aimed at overturning the Securities and Exchange Commission's SAB 121 regulation on digital assets. The resolution aims to reduce regulatory burden and promote regulated banks to safely hold digital assets. However, the White House supports the SEC and has threatened to veto the resolution, emphasizing that if the President receives H.J. Res. 109, he will veto it.