Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

5 Lessons from 2022 that Changed Crypto Forever

For many people, myself included, who were drawn to cryptocurrencies by the prospect of fixing or replacing an exclusionary, extractive, outdated global financial system, the failure in crypto markets this past year has delivered an extremely cold bath.

Now, to be clear, most of the massive financial hit to investors was not due to a failure of technology.

For the Bitcoin blockchain, for example, none of the drama of the past year matters. Every 10 minutes, day in, day out, it adds a block of transactions to its ever growing ledger. It’s a reminder that the global, decentralized networks of computers running Bitcoin, Ethereum and other permissionless blockchain’s protocols continue to forge systems for intermediary-free value exchange with which no one person or entity can interfere, regardless of the ups and downs of markets. The presence and persistence of these vast autonomous machines continue to leave me awe struck.

But “crypto” is more than protocols, smart contracts and cryptography. It’s also the community of humans who’ve gathered around this amalgam of technologies. Without this community, the technology can’t enter real-world adoption and foster change for good. And unfortunately, the failures in 2022 were due to their actions. While a few people in particular are rightly lumped with the bulk of the blame, there is mass collective responsibility here. The theft, deception and staggering breach of trust happened on our watch.

If we are to take lessons from the wealth destruction of 2022, the conclusion cannot be that this is all the fault of Sam Bankman-Fried and his ilk. SBF deserves the prison time he seems sure to receive with his extradition to the U.S., but the real question is how do we create a system – not merely a technological system but one of laws and standards – that makes it much harder for people like him to do what they did.

There is much work to do to build that system in 2023 and beyond. But it starts with the lessons of 2022. There are many. Here are the five that I think are the most important:

1. Crypto does not exist in an economic vacuum.

With all the headlines generated by the collapse of FTX in November, it’s easy to forget that far bigger losses hit cryptocurrency markets in the first months of the year – not because of a crypto-endemic scandal but because the Federal Reserve was hiking interest rates. That put an end to the surfeit of dollars pouring into speculative assets around the world, including cryptocurrencies. The macro environment matters.

2. Leverage, taken too far, always leads to contagion.

The domino effect, seen when the failure of one crypto institution quickly spreads to another, is hardly without precedent. It was there in the 1997 Asian financial crisis, the 1998 LTCM collapse, the 2008 subprime mortgage crisis and many other such moments in financial history. They all had the same characteristics: an overly bullish belief in the upward momentum of financial assets fueled an excessive build-up of loans to speculators. When those beliefs proved unfounded, the rush to the exits exposed an interdependent network of creditors and debtors as they dragged each other down in unison. Crypto speculation was never going to be immune from this, regardless of the decentralized nature of the underlying protocols.

3. DeFi is resilient, but needs constant economic and technical auditing.

Most of the high profile collapses in 2022 – FTX, Celsius, Voyager, Three Arrows Capital, Genesis – involved custody-holding CeFi (centralized finance) companies that put customer funds at risk. That has galvanized supporters of DeFi (decentralized finance), who rightly note that the most robust decentralized market-making and exchange systems survived, precisely because they lack a trusted intermediary capable of such abuse. Yet as of October, Chainalysis estimated that DeFi investors had lost a record $3 billion year-to-date, due to smart contract breaches, “rug pulls” by founders, and because the underlying tokenomics of some protocols were deeply flawed. (The destructive collapse in the Terra ecosystem was exemplary of the latter instance.) DeFi is a wild, volatile, confusing, unpredictable place. To achieve widespread participation, it needs a more comprehensive audit model in which trustworthy independent analysts or bounty-hunting developers assess projects’ code security, founder practices and tokenomics.

4. Back to basics: Crypto cannot be sustained on “number go up.”

In 2020 and 2021, when social media-driven meme coins were turning kids into instant millionaires, when DeFi projects were paying yields unavailable anywhere else in the world, and when institutional and retail investment sent crypto’s market capitalization up 15-fold to almost reach $3 trillion, we should all have been asking tougher questions. The most important one should have been: what’s underpinning all this? If we peel back the layers of interlocking protocols and the justifications for the returns they were promising, we’re left with little more than speculation for speculation’s sake. Most of this was built on momentum trading, on “number go up” expectations. It’s time to get back to basics and seek out real-world utility. Token returns need to point back to actual value cases, whether its cross-border payments, decentralized energy, new marketing models offered by non-fungible tokens (NFTs) or one of many other promising use cases.

5. Crypto needs an informed, independent, hard-hitting press.

Sure, this one’s self-interested, but 2022 proved it to be undeniably true that this industry needs a robust “Fourth Estate” to hold accountable the people and entities working within it. Permissionless blockchains should be viewed as public goods – much as the air we breathe, the water we drink or the highways we drive on are public goods. They must be protected as such, which means there must be transparency (balanced with a respect for individual privacy.) And while we are all enormously proud of the catalytic role CoinDesk played in exposing the FTX house of cards, it raises the question of why this wasn’t caught earlier. Answer: there aren’t enough crypto-savvy, professionally managed, independence-protected journalists covering this space. (That’s why we got those naive softball articles from The New York Times and others that glossed over SBF’s fraudulent behavior and got my colleague David Morris fired up.)

Still, here’s a hill I will die on: the requisite transparency is not something that can be achieved solely through the work of “citizen journalists” on Twitter or elsewhere. Those who claim the FTX debacle was brought to the fore by crowd-sourcing the sleuthing work of ordinary people on social media ignore the fact that the meltdown was triggered by an investigative article by Ian Allison, a trained journalist working within the structure of a professionally run newsroom, with editors and management who’ve carved out a position of independence from their proprietor to earn the trust of their readers. (CoinDesk is a subsidiary of DCG but operates independently and abides by a core code of ethics.) Before Ian’s piece, where was all that Twitter wisdom-of-the-crowd discovery?

If this industry is to thrive it can’t again be blindsided by revelations of wrongdoing as extreme as those uncovered in 2022. That requires vigilance to transparency and recognition that journalists who dig into issues at relevant institutions are doing a service to the longer-term interests of this industry rather than undermining it.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • BTC Falls Below $82,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $82,000, currently priced at $81,984.48, with a 24-hour decline of 2.01%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • BTC Drops Below $83,000

    Market data shows that BTC has fallen below $83,000, currently priced at $83,015.81, with a 24-hour decline of 0.46%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • ETH Surpasses $2500

    Market data shows that ETH has surpassed $2500, currently priced at $2500.4, with a 24-hour decline of 0.23%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • Standard Chartered Launches Cryptocurrency Trading Service in UAE for High-Net-Worth Clients

    On October 14, Standard Chartered announced the launch of a cryptocurrency trading service in the UAE aimed at high-net-worth clients, having obtained the relevant license from the Dubai Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority (VARA). Eligible clients can buy and sell BTC and ETH directly through their existing Standard Chartered accounts without the need for independent wallets or third-party trading platforms, with the bank responsible for asset custody and transaction settlement. This service is launched in partnership with Zodia Markets and is initially available only to professional investors in the UAE, with plans to expand to other markets in the future. Standard Chartered stated that this is the first direct cryptocurrency trading service offered to wealth management clients and the first of its kind by an international bank in the UAE.

  • US Spot Bitcoin ETF Sees Net Inflow of $175.7 Million Yesterday

    On October 14, according to monitoring data from Farside Investors, the US spot Bitcoin ETF saw a net inflow of $175.7 million yesterday.

  • US Spot Ethereum ETF Sees Net Inflow of $24.8 Million Yesterday

    On October 14, according to monitoring data from Farside Investors, the US spot Ethereum ETF experienced a net inflow of $24.8 million yesterday.

  • Solana to Launch Alpenglow Upgrade on October 21, Aiming for 150 Milliseconds Transaction Finality

    On October 14, Solana announced that the Alpenglow upgrade will officially activate on October 21 at approximately 14:50 UTC. This upgrade will replace the existing TowerBFT consensus with the Votor consensus. After the upgrade, the median transaction finality time is expected to be around 150 milliseconds, compared to the current value of approximately 12.8 seconds. The upgrade supports single-slot migration without the need for node restarts; it will also remove validator voting information from blocks, reducing operational costs. Even if the actual on-chain usage remains unchanged, statistics indicate that the total number of transactions reported is likely to decrease significantly. The current price of SOL is around $107, and there has not been a noticeable market reaction yet. From a narrative perspective, this upgrade is beneficial for Solana's speed and scalability story; however, Solana has experienced multiple network outages in the past, and this upgrade carries execution risks, serving as a potential warning signal.

  • South Korea Plans to Release Cryptocurrency Tax Guidelines Next Month

    On October 14, according to Yonhap News Agency, South Korea plans to release cryptocurrency tax guidelines next month in preparation for the cryptocurrency taxation policy set to be implemented in January 2027. Local traders in South Korea have been petitioning for a delay in the implementation of the tax policy, citing that the current regulations are not clear enough and the supporting infrastructure is still not fully developed.

  • Michael Saylor: New Bull Market Has Started, Bitcoin Expected to Surpass $100,000 Again

    On October 14, Michael Saylor, co-founder and Executive Chairman of Strategy, stated in an interview that Bitcoin has rebounded from its bottom and is expected to break through $100,000 again. He believes that Bitcoin previously bottomed out just below $60,000 and has now risen to the $80,000 range, with further increases anticipated. Saylor noted that improvements in the regulatory environment and banks accelerating their adoption of Bitcoin are driving the market into a new bull phase. He expects that in the coming years, Bitcoin's long-term annualized growth rate will reach 20% to 30%, and Strategy may increase its Bitcoin purchases during the bull market and issue more securities to fund these acquisitions. Additionally, regarding MSCI's consideration to adjust index rules and potentially exclude companies primarily engaged in accumulating assets from global stock indices, Saylor expressed opposition, arguing that such a move could set a negative precedent for the digital asset industry. MSCI is expected to announce its decision this Friday. Last November, JPMorgan estimated that if Strategy were excluded, it could face a risk of up to $2.8 billion in capital outflows.

  • Fed's Williams: One More Rate Hike This Year is Appropriate, No Need for Hikes in 2027

    On October 14, Federal Reserve's Williams stated that one more rate hike this year is appropriate; currently, he believes there is no need for rate hikes in 2027. There are no signs that the labor market is driving inflation, and apart from the AI and energy sectors, no widespread price pressures are observed in other areas.